agentsclimarketplace

Review & quality

19,284 rows, by stacks then stars

1,766 of these skill files have been read, by 1,273 distinct authors, and what they tell an agent counted. What Review & quality authors agree on, and what they forbid

  • Micro review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/MICRO-Skills/skills/micro-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how a MICRO submission is judged — the double-blind HotCRP pipeline from the April deadline through the June rebuttal/revision window to the early-July notification, what reviewers score in a microarchitecture paper, the professional-conduct rules, and how the new Industry Track review differs.

  • Misq review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/MIS-Quarterly-Skills/skills/misq-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to understand how MIS Quarterly's editorial process works and to read a decision letter — the double-anonymous model, the Senior-Editor/Associate-Editor routing where the SE owns the decision, what a major/minor revision versus reject signals, and what to expect across one or more revision rounds. Sets expectations and interprets decisions; the response itself is drafted with misq-rebuttal.

  • Misq submission

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/MIS-Quarterly-Skills/skills/misq-submission Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use for the final pre-submission preflight of a MIS Quarterly manuscript — confirming the ScholarOne workflow, Word-file format, double-anonymous compliance, the correct manuscript category and its page limit, the pluralistic transparency commitment uploaded at Step 2, and the reviewer-service agreement. Verifies submission readiness; it does not polish prose (misq-writing-style) or interpret decisions (misq-review-process).

  • Mlsys review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/MLSys-Skills/skills/mlsys-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how MLSys peer review works, covering the OpenReview workflow, the mixed ML-and-systems reviewer pool and how each half scores differently, the compressed response window, industrial-track review expectations, decision dynamics, and what the post-acceptance artifact stage means for review strategy.

  • Mgsci review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Management-Science-Skills/skills/mgsci-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to understand how Management Science (INFORMS) review and decisions work — the Department/area-editor desk screen, double-anonymized refereeing, the cross-department fit bar, official turnaround targets, and how to read a decision letter — before or after submitting. It explains the process; it does not draft the response (mgsci-rebuttal).

  • Msom review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Manufacturing-and-Service-Operations-Management-Skills/skills/msom-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to understand how Manufacturing & Service Operations Management (M&SOM) review and decisions work — the author-routed six-department structure, the Department Editor / Associate Editor / referee chain, double-anonymous review, special tracks (OM Forum, Practice Platform, OM Grand Challenges), and how to read a decision letter — before or after submitting.

  • Mksc review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Marketing-Science-Skills/skills/mksc-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when understanding how Marketing Science evaluates a manuscript — the double-anonymous Senior-Editor / Associate-Editor routing, what the first-pass and review look for, and how to read a decision letter. Explains the process; it does not draft the revision response (mksc-rebuttal).

  • Mathfin review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Mathematical-Finance-Skills/skills/mathfin-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when navigating the Mathematical Finance (Wiley) review process — single-blind editor screening, associate-editor handling, and referees who verify proofs line by line. Explains what reviewers at this theory venue check first, common desk-screen failure patterns for theorem-first papers, and how to read review-stage signals.

  • Mind review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Mind-Skills/skills/mind-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to understand how Mind evaluates a submission — triple-anonymous peer review, quality as the sole criterion, the role of expert referees, and what it means for a journal that receives over 800 submissions a year. Sets expectations and shapes the paper to survive review; it does not contact editors.

  • Mobicom review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/MobiCom-Skills/skills/mobicom-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about where a MobiCom paper sits in the two-round review process — the early-reject cut after round one, the released reviews and rebuttal window after round two, the accept / one-shot revision / reject outcome space, reviewer continuity across a revision, and how the rolling-deadline structure shapes what to do next.

  • Mobisys review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/MobiSys-Skills/skills/mobisys-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when explaining or planning around MobiSys peer review — the two-round process with an early-reject cut after round 1, the round-2 rebuttal window, double-blind HotCRP mechanics, the systems-and-services reviewer pool, and decision criteria for on-device claims, so response strategy fits how MobiSys decides.

  • Naacl author response

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/NAACL-Skills/skills/naacl-author-response Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when writing the ARR author response for a paper headed to NAACL — deciding which reviewer objections to spend the window on, drafting replies that give the action editor a citable meta-review sentence, and protecting the score record that NAACL's committee will later read at commitment.

  • Naacl review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/NAACL-Skills/skills/naacl-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how a NAACL decision actually gets made — the division of labor between ACL Rolling Review (reviews, meta-review) and the NAACL program committee (commitment-stage acceptance into Main or Findings), where author leverage exists at each stage, and how the skipped-year calendar shapes committee behavior.

  • Ndss review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/NDSS-Skills/skills/ndss-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when interpreting where an NDSS submission stands — the two-round pipeline inside each cycle, the early reject with Round-1 reviews, rebuttal and interactive discussion, the Accept / Minor Revision / Major Revision decision set, and the Ethics Review Board's role.

  • Nsdi review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/NSDI-Skills/skills/nsdi-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when interpreting where an NSDI submission stands — the per-deadline PC pipeline, the three-way outcome space of accept, one-shot revision, and reject, the cross-deadline resubmission ban, reviewer continuity across revisions, and what each decision letter actually commits the authors to.

  • Nbr rebuttal

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Nankai-Business-Review-Skills/skills/nbr-rebuttal Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to draft the revise-and-resubmit (R&R) response letter for 《南开管理评论》 (Nankai Business Review) — addressing reviewer concerns on theoretical contribution, mechanism logic, measurement (reliability/validity/CMV), analysis (mediation/moderation/HLM or experiment/qualitative rigor), and contextualization. Use only after the manuscript itself has been revised, not before.

  • Neurips review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/NeurIPS-Skills/skills/neurips-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when explaining or diagnosing the NeurIPS main-track review process, including OpenReview, reviewer and AC roles, contribution-type review, ethics flags, reciprocal reviewing, discussion, and LLM-review policy.

  • Newms review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/New-Media-and-Society-Skills/skills/newms-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when anticipating how a New Media & Society (NM&S) manuscript will be judged — anonymous (double-anonymized) peer review, what interdisciplinary referees weigh, and the decision categories. Sets expectations; it does not write the paper or the response letter.

  • Oopsla review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/OOPSLA-Skills/skills/oopsla-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when explaining or strategizing around OOPSLA's two-round review machinery — double-anonymous multi-stage reviewing, the four outcomes (Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, Reject), reviewer continuity across rounds, round-hopping a Major Revision, and how acceptance flows into a PACMPL issue and the SPLASH talk.

  • Osdi review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/OSDI-Skills/skills/osdi-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how an OSDI paper is reviewed and decided — the double-blind HotCRP PC pipeline with no author-response period, the two tracks, conditional acceptance with heavyweight shepherding, co-chair recusal, notification timing, and the Jay Lepreau Best Paper lineage.

  • Ors review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Operations-Research-Skills/skills/ors-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when navigating the Operations Research (OR) editorial process — the departmental area-editor routing, the soft double-anonymous model with asymmetric transparency, decision types, and how to read a decision letter from the handling Area Editor. Explains how review works and how to read a decision; it does not draft the response (ors-rebuttal) or run the preflight (ors-submission).

  • Orgsci review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Organization-Science-Skills/skills/orgsci-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when you want to understand how Organization Science review and decisions work before or after submitting — the decentralized senior-editor model with strong SE autonomy, the conflict-of-interest routing cascade, double-blind submission preparation, and how to read a decision letter at this venue.

  • Orgstud review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Organization-Studies-Skills/skills/orgstud-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when calibrating expectations for the Organization Studies (OS) review cycle — desk-screen odds, the developmental double-anonymized process, decision types, and how to read what reviewers and the handling editor are signalling. Sets expectations and reading strategy; it does not draft the response (see orgstud-rebuttal).

  • Pldi review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/PLDI-Skills/skills/pldi-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when interpreting PLDI's review pipeline — double-blind HotCRP reviewing by a PL-implementor PC, the February author-response window, March notification, up-to-10% Distinguished Paper selection, and how post-acceptance artifact evaluation and PACMPL publication follow the decision.

  • Pmla review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/PMLA-Skills/skills/pmla-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to understand how PMLA (Publications of the Modern Language Association) evaluates an essay — anonymous (blind) review with at least two reviewers, the Editorial Board's final decision, the Advisory Committee's reports, MLA-membership eligibility, and how anonymity is maintained. Sets expectations and shapes the essay to survive review; it does not contact editors.

  • Podc review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/PODC-Skills/skills/podc-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how an ACM PODC submission is evaluated — covering lightweight double-blind review, a program committee that reads proofs, the accept/reject decision with no journal-style revision round, the Brief Announcements track's lighter bar, and how PODC's process differs from DISC, SPAA, and the sequential-theory venues STOC/FOCS/SODA.

  • Pods artifact evaluation

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/PODS-Skills/skills/pods-artifact-evaluation Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use for the PODS analogue of artifact evaluation — there is no systems artifact track at this theory symposium, so this skill covers formal-claims verification instead: a complete at-submission proof appendix, a claim-to-proof mapping reviewers can check, the full-version-on-arXiv norm, and, only when a paper claims practicality, an honest optional code artifact.

  • Pods review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/PODS-Skills/skills/pods-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how an ACM PODS submission is evaluated, covering lightweight double-anonymous review, the multi-cycle-per-year calendar, the two reviewing rounds within a cycle, the 48-hour rebuttal, the accept/reject/revision decision with a shepherded revision, PACMMOD-track publication, and how PODS differs from SIGMOD's rounds and ICDT's process.

  • Popl review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/POPL-Skills/skills/popl-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when interpreting where a POPL submission stands — the full double-blind pipeline from the July HotCRP deadline through reviews, the optional author response, October conditional-acceptance decisions, the mandatory revision gate, Distinguished Paper selection, and publication as PACMPL Issue POPL in January.

  • Ppopp review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/PPoPP-Skills/skills/ppopp-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how a PPoPP submission is evaluated, covering double-blind review, the Program Committee plus External/Extended Review Committee model, TPMS reviewer matching, the author-response rebuttal, the accept/reject decision with automatic poster consideration, and how PPoPP's process differs from PLDI's and CGO's.

  • Prai review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Pattern-Recognition-and-Artificial-Intelligence-Skills/skills/prai-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    在需要理解《模式识别与人工智能》(Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence, PR&AI) 的同行评审流程并识别各环节作者杠杆时调用。覆盖编辑初审(宗旨/体例/字数/查重)→专家外审(官方口径一般6个月内给评审结果)→修回(可能多轮,较大修改重新送审)→主编终审→录用的完整链路、各环节的退稿/退修理由、超过6个月作者可通知编辑部自行处理的官方口径、以及作者在每个环节能施加影响的着力点。用于把审稿流程建模为可预期的阶段并规划应对;审稿是否双盲等细节以官网当期须知为准(待核实)。

  • Percom review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/PerCom-Skills/skills/percom-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how an IEEE PerCom research submission is evaluated, covering double-blind review, the three-TPC-member model, the early-rejection stage, the single-round bounded rebuttal gated by a "weak accept," the accept/reject decision, and how PerCom's process differs from ACM UbiComp/IMWUT's journal revise cycle.

  • Popdevr rebuttal

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Population-and-Development-Review-Skills/skills/popdevr-rebuttal Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when writing the response to a Population and Development Review (PDR, Wiley / Population Council) revise-and-resubmit. PDR review is double-anonymized and cross-field (demographers and development scholars), so the response must convert every expert reviewer on population substance and on the development meaning, without alienating the editor. Structures the response letter; it does not fabricate new results.

  • Popdevr review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Population-and-Development-Review-Skills/skills/popdevr-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when you need to understand how Population and Development Review (PDR, Wiley / Population Council) evaluates a manuscript — an editorial-committee screen before external review, double-anonymized peer review by at least two referees, and a typical ~3-month time to first decision. Sets expectations and shapes the paper to survive review; it does not contact editors.

  • Pom review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Production-and-Operations-Management-Skills/skills/pom-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when understanding or planning for Production and Operations Management (POM) review — Department Editor screening, double-blind review, the rigor-and-practice evaluation, and the strict no-resubmission-after-rejection rule. Explains the process and reads decisions; it does not draft the response (pom-rebuttal).

  • Phg review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Progress-in-Human-Geography-Skills/skills/phg-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when anticipating how a Progress in Human Geography (PiHG) review essay will be judged — the double-anonymous review model, decision categories, and the desk-reject triggers specific to a review journal. Explains what to expect; it does not draft the manuscript or the response letter.

  • Psychrev review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Psychological-Review-Skills/skills/psychrev-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when anticipating how a Psychological Review manuscript will be evaluated — masked peer review, the kinds of decisions, article types (full article vs. Theoretical Note), and what reviewers at a theory journal actually probe. Explains the process; it does NOT write the response document (that is psychrev-rebuttal) or run the submission preflight (psychrev-submission).

  • Psci review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Psychological-Science-Skills/skills/psci-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when you need to understand how Psychological Science evaluates a manuscript — anonymized peer review, editorial weighting of robustness, transparency, and preregistration quality, desk-reject and decline-without-review patterns, and the Registered Reports route. Use when stress-testing a paper before submission or interpreting a decision letter. Sets expectations and shapes the paper to survive review; it does not contact editors.

  • Pubar rebuttal

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Public-Administration-Review-Skills/skills/pubar-rebuttal Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when writing the response to a Public Administration Review (PAR) revise-and-resubmit. PAR weighs both scholarly rigor and the practitioner "so-what," so the response must convert each reviewer, satisfy the handling editor, and keep the Evidence for Practice intact. Structures the response letter; it does not fabricate new results.

  • Pubar review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Public-Administration-Review-Skills/skills/pubar-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when you need to understand how Public Administration Review (PAR) evaluates a manuscript — double-blind review, desk screening for fit/scope/practice-relevance, the reject / major / minor / accept decision spectrum, the role of Evidence for Practice, and the article types. Sets expectations and shapes the paper to survive review; it does not contact editors.

  • Poq review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Public-Opinion-Quarterly-Skills/skills/poq-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to understand how Public Opinion Quarterly (POQ) evaluates a manuscript — double-blind review via ScholarOne Manuscripts, typically two to three referees, the survey-methodology and AAPOR-disclosure bar reviewers apply, and how associate editors may request code/data during review. Sets expectations and shapes the paper to survive review; it does not contact editors.

  • Qe review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Quantitative-Economics-Skills/skills/qe-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to understand and plan around the Quantitative Economics (QE) editorial timeline — desk-reject risk, external refereeing, ~4-5 month target turnaround, 12-month revise windows, the Econometrica-transfer route, and the pre-acceptance ES Data Editor check. Sets expectations; it does not draft the paper.

  • Rje review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/RAND-Journal-of-Economics-Skills/skills/rje-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to understand and plan around The RAND Journal of Economics (RJE) review pipeline — the upfront editor screen (possible desk reject), peer review by two anonymous referees, and a final read by the handling Editor. Sets expectations and shapes a submission that clears the first screen.

  • Rss review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/RSS-Skills/skills/rss-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when explaining or strategizing around RSS (Robotics: Science and Systems) peer review — the double-blind OpenReview pipeline, the two-stage design where only above-threshold papers earn a one-page rebuttal, the Area Chair meeting that sets decisions, and what single-track selectivity does to reviewer expectations.

  • Recsys review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/RecSys-Skills/skills/recsys-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when explaining or planning around ACM RecSys peer review — the mutually-anonymous model with at least three PC members and a Senior PC overseer, the rebuttal phase, how the reproducibility-crisis culture shapes reviewer priorities, the offline-versus-online evaluation lens, and how acceptance leads to ACM Digital Library publication.

  • Respol review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Research-Policy-Skills/skills/respol-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when calibrating expectations and choreography for the Research Policy (RP) review cycle — the double-blind process, the out-of-scope desk screen, handling-editor routing, the Research Note option, and what RP referees reward versus reject. Sets expectations; it does not draft the response letter (respol-rebuttal).

  • Revacc review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Review-of-Accounting-Studies-Skills/skills/revacc-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when calibrating expectations for the Review of Accounting Studies (RAST) review cycle — its fast, first-round-decision culture, double-blind process, the RAST Conference path, and when to consider a sibling venue. Sets expectations and strategy; it does not run the submission preflight (revacc-submission) or draft the response letter (revacc-rebuttal).

  • Red review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Review-of-Economic-Dynamics-Skills/skills/red-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when understanding or planning around the Review of Economic Dynamics (RED) editorial process — the editor desk/suitability screen, single-anonymized refereeing with a minimum of two reviewers, and RED's fast-review orientation without promising a fixed decision date. Sets expectations and timelines; it is not the submission preflight (see red-submission).

  • Red workflow

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Review-of-Economic-Dynamics-Skills/skills/red-workflow Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when mapping the end-to-end lifecycle of a Review of Economic Dynamics (RED) manuscript — from confirming dynamic/quantitative scope, through the current Elsevier Guide's USD 195 fee and ScienceDirect/Editorial Manager submission, the single-anonymized two-reviewer process, the code-first data/code archive plus Option C data statement, to the revise-and-resubmit. Orchestration; it routes to the other red- skills rather than drafting content.

  • Restud replication package

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Review-of-Economic-Studies-Skills/skills/restud-replication-package Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when assembling the data and code deposit for an accepted empirical The Review of Economic Studies (REStud) manuscript, writing the README, or auditing reproducibility before the journal's Data Editor runs the pre-publication reproducibility check. Builds a deposit-ready package; does not run the analysis. Verify the current REStud/OUP data policy on the official page.

  • Revedres editor strategy

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Review-of-Educational-Research-Skills/skills/revedres-editor-strategy Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when anticipating editor and reviewer expectations, framing the contribution, and positioning scope for a Review of Educational Research (RER) submission. Aligns the review with how RER is refereed; it does not run the submission preflight (revedres-submission) or draft the response to reviewers (revedres-revision).

  • Revedres revision

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Review-of-Educational-Research-Skills/skills/revedres-revision Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when an editor/reviewer decision letter arrives on a Review of Educational Research (RER) review or meta-analysis and you must plan the revision and response. Turns the letter into action and a point-by-point reply; it does not run the submission preflight (revedres-submission) or re-architect the framework from scratch (revedres-organizing-framework).

  • Rof review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Review-of-Finance-Skills/skills/rof-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when interpreting Review of Finance desk screening, Screen Reports, double-blind review, top-three-finance-journal referee standards, two-round decision philosophy, Fast-Track timing, and sanctions for undisclosed resubmission or dual submission.

  • Rfs referee strategy

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/Review-of-Financial-Studies-Skills/skills/rfs-referee-strategy Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when choosing suggested/opposed referees or running an objection pre-mortem before submitting a The Review of Financial Studies (RFS) manuscript. Anticipates reviewer concerns; does NOT write the rebuttal (that is rfs-rebuttal).

  • Sigcomm review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/SIGCOMM-Skills/skills/sigcomm-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when explaining or planning around ACM SIGCOMM peer review — double-blind HotCRP reviewing, the early-reject cut for consensus rejections, the rebuttal for discussion-phase papers, the shepherd-run one-shot revision that ends in accept or reject only, shepherding of accepted papers, and how the outcome space shapes author strategy.

  • Siggraph review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/SIGGRAPH-Skills/skills/siggraph-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use to model the SIGGRAPH / SIGGRAPH Asia Technical Papers review pipeline and calibrate expectations, covering the single 6-point score scale, the primary/secondary/tertiary reviewer structure, the 1000-word rebuttal, the Technical Papers Committee meeting, conditional acceptance with second-stage verification, and the dual-track Journal-vs-Conference decision.

  • Sigir review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/SIGIR-Skills/skills/sigir-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how SIGIR evaluates submissions — the per-track OpenReview machinery, double-blind full/short review versus single-anonymous Resources review, the PC-member nomination duty, what IR reviewers score (evaluation validity above novelty claims), the ACM Peer Review Policy layer, and how decisions land.

  • Sigmetrics review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/SIGMETRICS-Skills/skills/sigmetrics-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how an ACM SIGMETRICS submission is evaluated, covering the hybrid conference-journal model, double-anonymous review, the three first-round outcomes (Accept-with-shepherding / One-Shot Revision / Reject), the one-shot revision resubmitted to a subsequent rolling deadline, the 12-month resubmission bar, and how SIGMETRICS differs from IMC, SIGCOMM, and NSDI.

  • Sigmod review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/SIGMOD-Skills/skills/sigmod-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how a SIGMOD research paper moves through a PACMMOD round, covering double-anonymous CMT reviewing, the author feedback phase, accept/reject/revision verdicts, the one-month revision window, the 12-month rejection embargo, and how database PC members actually weigh evidence.

  • Soda review process

    brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/SODA-Skills/skills/soda-review-process Skill

    1,416★ repo

    Use when reasoning about how a SODA (ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms) submission is evaluated — the per-edition program committee under joint ACM-SIAM sponsorship, HotCRP triage of a record-size submission pool, lightweight double-blind refereeing of full versions, the September rebuttal, and October decisions.