Problem analysis
Skill i-stack/ai-coding-kit/skills-engineering/problem-analysis
Sync your MCP servers, Agent Skills, and AI rules across Cursor, Claude Code, Cline & more in one click.
npx -y skills add i-stack/ai-coding-kit --skill problem-analysisAssembled from the repository path, not quoted from the project. Check it against their README if it does not work.
One thing to look at
- 1 stars1 stars. Stars are a popularity signal and not a quality one, but at this level it is likely that nobody has read this closely except its author, and you would be relying on your own review.
What its author says it does
Copied from the file, not written here
问题前置分析——逻辑检验、第一性原理拆解、充分理解后再回复(PA-001/002/003)。适用所有含判断或方案讨论的任务。
SKILL.md
1.8 KB, as published. Nobody here has run it
Problem Analysis
强制入口
命中本 skill 时,必须先完整阅读 references/problem_analysis.md 并按其中条款执行。
- 不得以 preamble 或摘要代替该文件全文。
三条核心规则
- [PA-001] 逻辑检验:收到问题后,先审查问题本身是否含逻辑错误、矛盾前提、循环假设或虚假二分。若发现,须先揭示,不得在错误前提上直接作答。
- [PA-002] 第一性原理:从底层需求拆解问题——实际要解决的是什么?当前提出的路径是否最优?若存在更优解或更深层需求,必须在正式回复前点明。
- [PA-003] 理解门控:PA-001 + PA-002 完成前不开始正式回复。若问题清晰且无问题,内部完成即可,不强制输出分析块;若发现偏差或更优路径,须输出
问题分析块。
细则见 references/problem_analysis.md。
何时加载
- 默认:收到任何技术问题、方案讨论、实现请求、架构取舍时。
- 跳过:纯机械执行(格式化代码、直接翻译)、无判断成分的信息复述。
与相邻 skill 的分工
| Skill | 分工 |
|---|---|
| problem-analysis(本 skill) | 分析问题本身的合理性与真实需求 |
logical-reasoning(GR-010) | 约束 AI 自身回复的论证质量 |
engineering-discipline(GR-002) | 问题描述不清时前置确认 |
cognitive-expansion(Tier 0/3) | 回复后的认知拓展 |