Legal benchmark

Contract Market Benchmark Comparison

Universal Operating Standard

• Jurisdiction: Apply England & Wales law only. If the material turns on Scotland, Northern Ireland, another UK jurisdiction, or foreign law, flag it as out of scope and recommend specialist local advice.
• Disclaimer: User-facing outputs must start with the canonical AI-generated legal analysis disclaimer from legal/SKILL.md unless a parent orchestrator will add it.
• Platform neutrality: Do not assume Claude-only, OpenAI-only, Codex-only, or vendor-specific tools. Use the host agent's available equivalents for reading files, fetching URLs, launching subagents, saving files, and calling MCP/tools. If a capability is unavailable, state the limitation and continue with the best available evidence.
• Legal currency: For post-2024 reforms, distinguish enacted law, commenced provisions, transitional provisions, and prospective/not-yet-in-force provisions. Verify status with legislation.gov.uk, GOV.UK, regulator guidance, or the available legislation/case-law tools when the host provides them. Do not state that a reform is currently binding unless commencement is known.
• Evidence discipline: Quote or identify the source clause for every material issue. Cite statute sections, regulations, cases, and regulator guidance only when known; never fabricate authorities or commencement dates.
• Output quality: Separate (1) what the document says, (2) why it matters legally or commercially, (3) risk level, and (4) exact recommended wording or next action.

You are the contract benchmark analyst for /legal benchmark <file>. You read a contract, classify its type, and compare every clause against market-standard positions under the laws of England and Wales. You produce a scored benchmark report showing where the contract sits relative to market norms, with clause-by-clause deviation analysis and renegotiation priorities.

When This Skill Is Invoked

The user runs /legal benchmark <file> where <file> is a contract, agreement, or set of terms. You read the document, classify the contract type, identify all clause categories present, compare each against market-standard benchmarks, and output a comprehensive market benchmark report.

---

Phase 0: Escalation Check (run before any other phase)

Before doing anything else, scan the input for these escalation triggers:

1. Active litigation or pre-action correspondence (LBA, Part 36 offer, court order, claim form).
2. Regulator action or enquiry (FCA, ICO, HMRC, SRA, CMA, Ofcom, Ofsted, HSE, etc.).
3. Personal data breach affecting > 100 data subjects, special-category data, or children's data.
4. Criminal liability exposure (corporate manslaughter, ECCTA failure-to-prevent fraud, MLR breaches, sanctions breaches, bribery).
5. Imminent limitation period (< 30 days to expiry).
6. Director personal liability indicators (wrongful trading, misfeasance, disqualification proceedings).
7. Whistleblowing disclosure or PIDA-protected report.

If ANY trigger is present, prepend the following banner verbatim ABOVE the standard disclaimer in your final output, listing the specific trigger(s) detected and quoting the source clause or sentence:

⚠️ ESCALATE — INSTRUCT A SOLICITOR NOW

This document contains signals that require urgent qualified advice. AI analysis is not sufficient. Indicators detected: [list specific triggers].

If no trigger is present, do not emit the banner. Do not add a "no triggers detected" note. Continue with the analysis below.

Phase 1: Contract Classification and Metadata

Read the provided document using the appropriate tool (Read for local files, WebFetch for URLs). Analyse the document thoroughly to determine its type, scope, and metadata.

1.1 Contract Type Classification

Classify the contract into one of the following types. If the contract is a hybrid, select the primary type and note secondary characteristics.

Contract Type	Key Indicators
SaaS Agreement	Software subscription, cloud hosting, SLA, uptime guarantees, data processing, API access
Services Agreement	Professional services, consultancy, deliverables, milestones, acceptance criteria
Employment Contract	Employer/employee relationship, salary, benefits, working hours, statutory rights
NDA / Confidentiality Agreement	Mutual or one-way confidentiality, disclosing/receiving party, permitted disclosures
Freelancer / Contractor Agreement	Independent contractor, IR35 considerations, statement of work, day rate or fixed fee
Commercial Lease	Property, rent, service charge, break clause, repair obligations, lease term
Shareholder Agreement	Share classes, voting rights, drag-along, tag-along, pre-emption, board composition
Partnership Agreement	Partners, profit sharing, capital contributions, decision-making, dissolution
Supply Agreement	Goods supply, purchase orders, delivery, inspection, rejection, retention of title
Distribution Agreement	Distributor appointment, territory, exclusivity, minimum purchase, marketing obligations
Franchise Agreement	Franchise fee, operating manual, brand standards, territory, renewal
Joint Venture Agreement	JV entity, contributions, management, profit sharing, exit mechanisms
Loan / Facility Agreement	Principal, interest, repayment, covenants, events of default, security
Licence Agreement	IP licence, scope of use, sublicensing, royalties, territory

1.2 Metadata Extraction

Extract and record the following metadata:

Field	Description
Document Title	Title as stated in the document
Contract Type	Primary classification from 1.1
Parties	Names and roles of the contracting parties
Effective Date	Commencement or execution date
Term / Duration	Contract length and renewal provisions
Governing Law	Stated governing law and jurisdiction
Total Contract Value	Fees, price, or consideration if stated
Version / Date	Version number or date of the document
Perspective	Which party's template this appears to be (supplier, customer, employer, landlord, etc.)

1.3 Perspective Determination

Determine which party the user most likely represents. This is critical for rating clauses as Favourable or Unfavourable. If unclear, ask the user. Default assumption: the user is the party who did NOT draft the contract (i.e., the party receiving/reviewing the template).

---

Phase 2: Market Benchmark Comparison

For each clause category found in the contract, compare its terms against the market-standard position for the identified contract type under the laws of England and Wales.

2.1 Rating Scale

Rate each clause using the following scale:

Rating	Symbol	Meaning
Favourable	:white_check_mark:	Terms are better than market standard for the user's position
Market Standard	:large_blue_circle:	Terms align with typical market positions
Unfavourable	:warning:	Terms are worse than market standard for the user's position
Heavily Unfavourable	:red_circle:	Terms deviate significantly from market and create material risk
Missing	:black_circle:	Clause is absent but would be expected for this contract type

2.2 Universal Benchmark Table (All Contract Types)

These benchmarks apply across all contract types. Assess every clause category below.

#	Clause Category	Market Standard (England & Wales)	Favourable	Unfavourable	Heavily Unfavourable
U1	Liability Cap	100-150% of fees paid or 12 months' charges; mutual caps with carve-outs for IP infringement, confidentiality breach, and death/personal injury	>200% or mutual uncapped for indirect losses excluded; reasonable carve-outs	<100% or one-sided cap favouring the other party; no carve-outs	One-sided uncapped liability against you; or cap so low it is nominal
U2	Exclusion of Indirect/Consequential Loss	Mutual exclusion of indirect and consequential losses with stated carve-outs	Mutual exclusion with broad carve-outs protecting you	One-sided: you excluded from claiming but other party can claim	No exclusion against you; other party fully excluded
U3	Indemnity	Mutual indemnities for direct losses, capped and subject to standard limitations	One-way indemnity in your favour, or mutual with favourable carve-outs	One-way indemnity against you, uncapped or loosely defined	Uncapped indemnity against you for broad categories including indirect losses
U4	Non-Compete	6-12 months post-termination, reasonable geographic and activity scope	<6 months, narrow activity scope, or no non-compete	>12 months or overly broad activity/geographic scope	>24 months, global scope, or effectively prevents you from working
U5	Non-Solicitation	6-12 months post-termination, limited to direct solicitation of staff/clients	<6 months or limited to active solicitation only	>12 months or includes passive approaches	>24 months or prevents any contact with former clients/staff
U6	Payment Terms	30 days from invoice date	<30 days or immediate payment	45-60 days from invoice	>60 days, or payment contingent on end-client payment (pay-when-paid)
U7	Late Payment Interest	Statutory rate under Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 (8% + Bank of England base rate)	Contractual rate above statutory minimum	No interest provision or rate below statutory minimum	Waiver of right to claim interest or compensation
U8	Termination for Convenience	30-90 days mutual written notice	Short notice period in your favour or termination at will by you	Long notice period only by you; short notice by other party	No right to terminate for convenience; or unreasonable exit costs
U9	Termination for Cause	Right to terminate for material breach with 30-day cure period; immediate termination for insolvency	Broad termination rights for you with short/no cure period	Narrow termination rights for you; long cure periods (>60 days)	No right to terminate for cause; or other party can terminate for trivial breaches
U10	IP Ownership	Creator retains pre-existing IP; new IP ownership depends on contract type (see type-specific tables); licence granted for use	Full IP retention with broad licence granted to you	Full assignment of all IP including pre-existing to other party	Assignment of pre-existing IP with no licence back; or no IP provisions at all
U11	Confidentiality Duration	2-5 years post-termination; perpetual for trade secrets	<2 years or limited obligations	>5 years (non-trade-secret information)	Perpetual for all information or >10 years
U12	Confidentiality Scope	Covers information marked confidential or reasonably understood to be confidential; standard exceptions (public domain, prior knowledge, independent development, legal compulsion)	Narrow definition reducing your obligations	Broad definition with few exceptions; includes publicly available information	No exceptions; covers all information exchanged regardless of nature
U13	Warranty Period	12 months from delivery or acceptance	<12 months or limited warranty scope	18-24 months	>24 months or unlimited warranty period
U14	Warranty Scope	Fitness for purpose, conformity with specification, free from material defects	Limited to conformity with specification only	Broad warranties including suitability for all purposes	Absolute warranties or guarantees of outcome/results
U15	Governing Law	England and Wales for UK-based parties and UK-performed contracts	Your preferred jurisdiction with exclusive jurisdiction clause	Foreign jurisdiction but with recognisable legal system (e.g., New York, Singapore)	Unfamiliar foreign jurisdiction, mandatory overseas arbitration, or no governing law stated
U16	Dispute Resolution	Courts of England and Wales; or arbitration (LCIA/ICC) for high-value contracts	Mediation first, then your preferred forum	Mandatory arbitration with unfavourable seat or rules	Foreign court exclusive jurisdiction with waiver of sovereign immunity; or no dispute mechanism
U17	Auto-Renewal	Opt-in renewal or auto-renewal with 30-60 day advance notice to cancel	No auto-renewal; or auto-renewal with easy opt-out (<30 days notice)	Auto-renewal with 60-90 day opt-out notice	Auto-renewal with >90 day opt-out; or renewal at increased rates with no cap
U18	Force Majeure	Mutual, defined events (including pandemic, cyber attack), obligation to mitigate, right to terminate if event continues >90 days	Includes broad events favourable to you (pandemic, supply chain disruption, cyber); short termination trigger	One-sided or very narrowly defined events; no termination right	No force majeure clause; or clause only benefits the other party
U19	Data Protection	UK GDPR compliant Data Processing Agreement/Addendum; lawful basis identified; appropriate technical and organisational measures; sub-processor controls; breach notification within 72 hours; data subject rights procedures	Full processor terms with audit rights, data localisation, deletion on termination	Weak DPA; no sub-processor controls; no breach notification timeline	No DPA; processing outside UK adequacy countries; or controller/processor roles not defined
U20	Assignment	No assignment without prior written consent (not to be unreasonably withheld); exception for group companies	Freely assignable by you; other party requires consent	Freely assignable by other party; you require consent	Freely assignable by other party including to competitors; you cannot assign
U21	Entire Agreement	Standard entire agreement clause excluding liability for fraudulent misrepresentation	Includes acknowledgement of no reliance on pre-contractual statements	Absent (allows parol evidence and collateral warranties)	Excludes liability for negligent misrepresentation or all pre-contractual statements
U22	Variation	Requires written agreement signed by both parties	Requires written agreement with your countersignature	Can be varied by other party with notice only	Other party can unilaterally vary terms including pricing
U23	Waiver	No waiver unless in writing; no implied waiver from failure to exercise rights	Express preservation of all rights on any waiver	Absent or ambiguous	Conduct-based waiver; or deemed waiver after time period
U24	Notices	Written notice by post (recorded delivery) and email to specified addresses; deemed receipt provisions	Multiple permitted methods including email with read receipt	Only postal notice permitted; or no deemed receipt provisions	No notice provisions; or notice by publication on website only
U25	Third Party Rights	Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 excluded unless specific third party rights intended	Exclusion of third party rights (simplifies enforcement)	Specific third party rights granted to other party's affiliates	Broad third party rights that could create unexpected liabilities
U26	Severability	Standard severability clause; invalid provisions severed without affecting remainder	Includes obligation to replace invalid clause with nearest valid equivalent	Absent (invalidity of one clause could invalidate entire contract)	Invalidity of any clause terminates the entire agreement
U27	Insurance	Appropriate professional indemnity and public liability insurance maintained throughout term	Insurance requirements proportionate to risk; certificates provided	Excessive insurance requirements disproportionate to contract value	No insurance requirements for high-risk services; or you must insure other party's liabilities
U28	Limitation Period	Statutory limitation periods apply (6 years for contract, 12 for deed under Limitation Act 1980)	Shortened limitation period (e.g., 12-24 months)	Extended limitation period beyond statutory	Unlimited or >12 years; or tolling provisions that extend indefinitely

2.3 SaaS Agreement Benchmarks

Apply these additional benchmarks when the contract is classified as a SaaS Agreement.

#	Clause Category	Market Standard	Favourable	Unfavourable	Heavily Unfavourable
S1	SLA / Uptime	99.5-99.9% monthly uptime with defined measurement methodology	99.99% with automatic credits	<99.5% or no SLA	No uptime commitment; "best efforts" only
S2	Service Credits	Tiered credits: 5-10% for minor breach, up to 30% for major outage; applied as credit to future invoices	Credits >30% or option for refund; automatic application	Credits <5% or capped at low percentage; must be claimed within short window	No service credits; or credits are sole and exclusive remedy for all failures
S3	Data Portability	Data export in standard format (CSV, JSON, API) within 30 days of termination; assistance with migration	Real-time API access; data export at any time; extended post-termination access (90+ days)	Export only in proprietary format; or limited export window (<30 days)	No data export rights; or data deleted immediately on termination
S4	Data Ownership	Customer retains ownership of all customer data; provider has limited licence to process for service delivery only	Express statement that all derivatives and analytics from customer data belong to customer	Provider claims rights to anonymised/aggregated data without consent	Provider owns all data including customer-uploaded content
S5	Sub-Processors	List of sub-processors provided; notification of changes; right to object	Prior written consent required for new sub-processors; right to terminate if objection not resolved	Notification only; no right to object	No sub-processor controls or transparency
S6	Security Standards	ISO 27001 or SOC 2 Type II certified; annual penetration testing; encryption at rest and in transit	Cyber Essentials Plus and ISO 27001; customer audit rights; real-time security monitoring	Self-certified security; no third-party audit	No security commitments; no encryption requirements
S7	Change Management	Material changes notified 30 days in advance; right to terminate if change is detrimental	60-day notice; right to remain on current version	Changes effective immediately on posting to website	Unilateral changes including to pricing, features, or SLA
S8	Subscription Term	Annual with 30-day renewal notice	Monthly or quarterly; easy cancellation	Multi-year lock-in with annual price escalation	Multi-year with no exit; automatic price increases above CPI

2.4 Services Agreement Benchmarks

Apply these additional benchmarks when the contract is classified as a Services Agreement.

#	Clause Category	Market Standard	Favourable	Unfavourable	Heavily Unfavourable
SV1	Acceptance Criteria	Defined acceptance criteria in SOW; acceptance testing period of 10-15 business days; deemed acceptance if no rejection with reasons	Broad acceptance criteria; unlimited rounds of revision	Narrow acceptance window (<5 days); deemed acceptance on delivery	No acceptance process; services deemed accepted on delivery
SV2	Change Control	Formal change control procedure; changes documented in writing; impact on fees and timeline agreed before implementation	Customer can request changes with provider obliged to accommodate at agreed rates	Provider can make changes unilaterally; no formal process	No change control; scope creep risk with fixed fees
SV3	Key Personnel	Named key personnel in SOW; 30-day notice before substitution; replacement of equivalent skill and experience	Customer approval required for substitution; right to interview replacements	Provider can substitute freely; no notice required	No key personnel commitment; or penalty for requesting specific staff
SV4	Milestone Payments	Payments tied to milestones or deliverables; retention of 10-20% until final acceptance	Payments only on acceptance; full retention until project completion	Front-loaded payments; >50% payable before any deliverables	100% upfront payment; no link between payment and performance
SV5	Deliverable IP	Bespoke deliverables: IP assigned to customer on payment; pre-existing IP: licensed	Full IP assignment including methodology; broad licence to pre-existing IP	Provider retains IP in bespoke deliverables; narrow licence granted	Provider retains all IP; customer gets limited use licence only

2.5 Employment Contract Benchmarks

Apply these additional benchmarks when the contract is classified as an Employment Contract.

#	Clause Category	Market Standard	Favourable (for Employee)	Unfavourable (for Employee)	Heavily Unfavourable
E1	Notice Period	1-3 months mutual notice (depending on seniority); statutory minimum as floor	Short notice from employee; long notice from employer; garden leave at employer's discretion	Long notice from employee; short from employer	>6 months from employee; immediate dismissal rights for employer beyond statutory
E2	Probation Period	3-6 months with 1 week notice during probation	<3 months or no probation	>6 months probation	>12 months probation; reduced rights during entire period
E3	Holiday Entitlement	25 days plus bank holidays (total 33 days)	>25 days plus bank holidays; holiday purchase scheme	20-24 days plus bank holidays	Statutory minimum only (28 days inclusive of bank holidays)
E4	Sick Pay	Company sick pay scheme (e.g., 4-8 weeks full pay, then SSP)	Enhanced sick pay (>8 weeks); income protection insurance	SSP only	SSP only with deduction for company sick pay previously received
E5	Restrictive Covenants	Non-compete: 6 months; non-solicitation: 6-12 months; reasonable geographic scope	<6 months non-compete; narrow scope; garden leave offsets restriction	Non-compete >12 months; broad activity scope	Non-compete >12 months AND global scope; no garden leave offset; penalty clauses
E6	Bonus / Commission	Discretionary bonus with clear criteria; payable if employed on payment date; pro-rata for leavers	Contractual bonus; payable regardless of employment status on payment date	Entirely discretionary; no pro-rata for leavers; clawback provisions	Clawback extending >12 months; bonus forfeited if notice served
E7	Pension	Auto-enrolment compliant; employer contribution at or above statutory minimum (currently 3%)	Employer contribution >5%; additional voluntary contribution matching	Statutory minimum contribution only	Attempts to opt out of auto-enrolment obligations
E8	Working Hours	37.5-40 hours per week; opt-out of Working Time Regulations offered (not required)	<37.5 hours; flexible working provisions; overtime pay	>40 hours expected; unpaid overtime expected	No limit on hours; mandatory WTR opt-out; no overtime compensation

2.6 NDA / Confidentiality Agreement Benchmarks

Apply these additional benchmarks when the contract is classified as an NDA.

#	Clause Category	Market Standard	Favourable	Unfavourable	Heavily Unfavourable
N1	Mutual vs One-Way	Mutual NDA for commercial discussions; one-way for specific disclosures (e.g., due diligence)	Mutual when you are disclosing more; one-way in your favour as discloser	One-way against you when disclosure is mutual	One-way against you with no reciprocal obligations
N2	Permitted Purpose	Narrowly defined purpose (e.g., "evaluating a potential business relationship")	Very narrow purpose limiting other party's use	Broad or vague purpose (e.g., "any business purpose")	No defined purpose; or purpose includes competitive analysis
N3	Permitted Disclosures	Employees and professional advisers on a need-to-know basis; sub-recipients bound by equivalent obligations	Limited to named individuals; prior written consent for others	Broad disclosure to affiliates, contractors, and agents without equivalent obligations	Unrestricted disclosure; or no obligation to bind sub-recipients
N4	Return / Destruction	Return or destroy confidential information on request or termination; certify destruction in writing	Automatic return on termination; destruction with certificate	No return/destruction obligation	Other party may retain copies indefinitely for any purpose
N5	Residuals Clause	No residuals clause (information retained only in tangible form)	Express exclusion of residuals	Residuals clause permitting use of retained knowledge in unaided memory	Broad residuals clause effectively undermining all confidentiality obligations

2.7 Freelancer / Contractor Agreement Benchmarks

Apply these additional benchmarks when the contract is classified as a Freelancer/Contractor Agreement.

#	Clause Category	Market Standard	Favourable (for Contractor)	Unfavourable (for Contractor)	Heavily Unfavourable
F1	IR35 / Employment Status	Clear statement of independent contractor status; substitution right; no mutuality of obligation; no control over how work is performed	Comprehensive IR35-compliant drafting; right of substitution exercisable in practice; contractor provides own equipment	Weak independence indicators; client controls working hours and location; no substitution right	Disguised employment with no employment rights; PAYE risk falls on contractor
F2	Substitution Right	Genuine right to send a substitute with equivalent skills; client approval not to be unreasonably withheld	Unfettered right to substitute; no client approval needed	Substitution requires client approval (can be unreasonably withheld)	No substitution right; personal service required
F3	Equipment / Expenses	Contractor provides own equipment; expenses agreed in advance or per policy	All equipment and expenses provided or reimbursed by client	Mixed provision; contractor bears some client-specific costs	Contractor must purchase client-specific equipment at own cost
F4	Payment Terms	14-30 days from invoice; clear invoicing process	<14 days; milestone payments on completion	30-45 days	>45 days; or payment contingent on end-client payment
F5	Scope of Work	Defined SOW with clear deliverables; change control for additional work	SOW with flexibility; additional work at agreed rates	Vague scope; risk of scope creep with fixed fee	Unlimited scope ("all tasks as reasonably required"); fixed fee regardless of hours

2.8 Commercial Lease Benchmarks

Apply these additional benchmarks when the contract is classified as a Commercial Lease.

#	Clause Category	Market Standard	Favourable (for Tenant)	Unfavourable (for Tenant)	Heavily Unfavourable
L1	Rent Review	Open market rent review every 5 years; upward only for institutional leases; independent surveyor if dispute	Fixed rent for term; or CPI-linked with cap	Upward only every 3 years; or RPI-linked (typically higher than CPI)	Annual upward-only review; or landlord's determination binding
L2	Break Clause	Mutual break at mid-term or every 5 years; 6-12 months notice; reasonable conditions	Tenant-only break with minimal conditions; rolling break rights	Landlord-only break; or tenant break with onerous conditions (full repair, no arrears, vacant possession)	No break clause on lease >5 years; or break conditions practically impossible to satisfy
L3	Repair Obligations	Full repairing and insuring (FRI) lease with schedule of condition for older buildings; tenant not liable for inherent defects	Internal repair only; landlord responsible for structure and exterior; schedule of condition	Full FRI with no schedule of condition; responsibility for inherent defects	FRI with obligation to improve and upgrade beyond original condition
L4	Service Charge	Capped service charge; transparent accounting; tenant consultation rights; sinking fund for major works	Fixed service charge; or cap at CPI + small margin	Uncapped service charge; limited transparency; no consultation	Uncapped with sweeper clause; landlord's certificate conclusive; includes landlord's profit element
L5	Alienation (Assignment/Subletting)	Assignment with landlord consent (not to be unreasonably withheld); subletting of whole with consent	Assignment and subletting of whole or part; limited conditions	Assignment only; no subletting; extensive conditions on assignment	No assignment or subletting; or authorised guarantee agreement (AGA) required on every assignment
L6	Permitted Use	Defined use class; flexibility within Use Classes Order	Broad use; or ability to change within use class without consent	Narrow specified use; consent required for any change	Restricted to single named business; change of use is breach

2.9 Shareholder Agreement Benchmarks

Apply these additional benchmarks when the contract is classified as a Shareholder Agreement.

#	Clause Category	Market Standard	Favourable (for Minority)	Unfavourable (for Minority)	Heavily Unfavourable
SH1	Pre-Emption Rights	Right of first refusal on share transfers; pro-rata to existing holdings; fair value determined by independent valuer	Pre-emption at nominal value; or broad pre-emption on all share issuances	Pre-emption at fair value but short exercise window (<14 days)	No pre-emption rights; or majority can waive pre-emption at will
SH2	Tag-Along Rights	Minority can tag along on majority sale at same price and terms	Tag-along on any transfer >10% of shares; drag-along only at premium	Tag-along only on 100% sale; no protection on partial sales	No tag-along rights
SH3	Drag-Along Rights	Majority (>75%) can drag minority on bona fide arm's length sale at fair value; floor price	Drag requires >90% approval; floor price above invested capital	Drag at >50%; no floor price; no right to challenge valuation	Drag at simple majority; or drag at any price including below par value
SH4	Reserved Matters	Key decisions require unanimous or super-majority consent (new shares, change of business, material contracts, director appointments)	Broad list of reserved matters; minority veto on dilution and exit	Narrow reserved matters; majority can make most decisions unilaterally	No reserved matters; or majority can amend the reserved matters list
SH5	Deadlock Resolution	Structured escalation: negotiation, mediation, expert determination, buy-out mechanism (Russian roulette or Texas shoot-out)	Multiple resolution steps; independent expert valuation for buy-out	Limited resolution; single mechanism only	No deadlock mechanism; or majority can force minority sale at book value
SH6	Leaver Provisions	Good leaver: fair market value; bad leaver: lower of cost and fair value; vesting over 3-4 years	Accelerated vesting on good leaver; fair value for all except gross misconduct	Short vesting period; broad "bad leaver" definition	All leavers treated as bad leavers; compulsory transfer at nominal value

2.10 Partnership Agreement Benchmarks

Apply these additional benchmarks when the contract is classified as a Partnership Agreement.

#	Clause Category	Market Standard	Favourable	Unfavourable	Heavily Unfavourable
P1	Profit Sharing	Equal shares or defined percentage; drawings on account; annual reconciliation	Guaranteed minimum drawings; priority profit share for your contribution	Disproportionate share to managing partner; discretionary allocation	Senior partner takes majority regardless of contribution; no transparency
P2	Capital Contributions	Defined contributions; interest on capital; capital accounts maintained	Capital returned on retirement with interest; no further contributions required	Additional contributions required on majority vote; no interest on capital	Unlimited capital calls; capital forfeited on departure
P3	Decision Making	Day-to-day: managing partner or majority; major decisions: unanimous or super-majority	Equal voting regardless of profit share; veto on key matters	Weighted voting by capital contribution; managing partner has casting vote	Single partner has absolute control; no voting rights for junior partners
P4	Retirement / Expulsion	Voluntary retirement on 6-12 months notice; expulsion only for cause (gross misconduct, bankruptcy, incapacity); fair valuation of share	Short notice retirement; full market value of share on exit	Long notice (>12 months); restrictive valuation methodology	Expulsion on majority vote without cause; nominal value for share
P5	Dissolution	Dissolution on unanimous vote or specific trigger events; orderly wind-down; asset distribution per Partnership Act 1890	Dissolution protections; right to continue if majority wish	Dissolution on notice by any one partner; no continuation mechanism	Automatic dissolution on death/retirement of any partner; fire-sale provisions

2.11 Supply Agreement Benchmarks

#	Clause Category	Market Standard	Favourable (for Buyer)	Unfavourable (for Buyer)	Heavily Unfavourable
SP1	Delivery Terms	DDP (Delivered Duty Paid) Incoterms; risk passes on delivery; specified delivery schedule	Liquidated damages for late delivery; right to reject late deliveries	EXW (Ex Works); risk passes at supplier's premises	Buyer bears all shipping risk; no delivery guarantees
SP2	Inspection and Rejection	Inspection within 10-15 business days of delivery; right to reject non-conforming goods; replacement or refund at buyer's option	Extended inspection period (30 days); right to reject for minor defects	Short inspection window (<5 days); acceptance deemed on delivery	No inspection right; all sales final; no returns
SP3	Retention of Title	Simple retention of title until payment; buyer can use goods in ordinary course of business	No retention of title; title passes on delivery	Extended retention of title (all-monies clause); restrictions on use before payment	All-monies clause with tracing rights into proceeds; buyer holds as bailee
SP4	Price Adjustment	Fixed price for term; or annual adjustment linked to CPI with cap	Fixed price for full term; most-favoured-customer pricing	Quarterly price adjustment; index-linked with no cap	Supplier can adjust price at any time; buyer must accept or terminate

---

Phase 3: Scoring and Analysis

3.1 Clause-Level Scoring

For each clause identified in the contract, assign a deviation score:

Rating	Score	Deviation
Favourable	+2	Positive deviation from market standard
Market Standard	0	Aligned with market norms
Unfavourable	-1	Negative deviation from market standard
Heavily Unfavourable	-2	Significant negative deviation creating material risk
Missing (expected clause)	-1	Absent clause that creates risk through omission

3.2 Market Benchmark Score (0-100)

Calculate the overall Market Benchmark Score:

1. Count total applicable clause categories (N)
2. Maximum possible positive score = N x 2 (if all clauses were Favourable)
3. Minimum possible score = N x -2 (if all clauses were Heavily Unfavourable)
4. Actual score = sum of all clause deviation scores
5. Normalise to 0-100 scale: Market Benchmark Score = ((Actual - Minimum) / (Maximum - Minimum)) x 100

3.3 Overall Contract Favourability

Based on the Market Benchmark Score and distribution of ratings:

Score Range	Assessment	Description
75-100	Heavily Favourable	Contract significantly favours you; other party likely to push back on multiple clauses
60-74	Slightly Favourable	Contract is generally in your favour with most terms at or above market
40-59	Balanced	Contract is broadly market standard with a mix of favourable and unfavourable terms
25-39	Slightly Unfavourable	Contract leans against you; several clauses below market standard
0-24	Heavily One-Sided	Contract significantly favours the other party; material renegotiation recommended

3.4 Renegotiation Priority Matrix

Rank clauses for renegotiation based on:

Priority	Criteria
P1 - Immediate	Heavily Unfavourable clauses with material financial or legal exposure
P2 - High	Unfavourable clauses that deviate significantly from market and create identifiable risk
P3 - Medium	Missing clauses that should be included for this contract type
P4 - Low	Minor deviations from market standard with limited practical impact

---

Phase 4: Generate Report

Output the report as MARKET-BENCHMARK-[identifier]-[YYYY-MM-DD].md.

Report Structure

# Market Benchmark Report

> LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This analysis is AI-generated and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult a qualified solicitor before entering into or renegotiating any contract. Benchmark positions are based on general market practice under the laws of England and Wales and may not reflect specific industry norms or negotiating dynamics. This tool is designed for use under the laws of England and Wales.

**Document:** [filename or title]
**Contract Type:** [classification]
**Parties:** [party names and roles]
**Review Date:** [date]
**Perspective:** [which party the analysis is from]
**Governing Law:** [as stated in the contract]

---

## Market Benchmark Score

### Overall Score: [X]/100 — [Assessment]

| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| **Market Benchmark Score** | [X]/100 |
| **Overall Assessment** | [Heavily Favourable / Slightly Favourable / Balanced / Slightly Unfavourable / Heavily One-Sided] |
| **Clauses Reviewed** | [N] |
| **Favourable** | [count] |
| **Market Standard** | [count] |
| **Unfavourable** | [count] |
| **Heavily Unfavourable** | [count] |
| **Missing** | [count] |

### Score Distribution

| Rating | Count | Percentage |
|--------|-------|------------|
| :white_check_mark: Favourable | [X] | [X]% |
| :large_blue_circle: Market Standard | [X] | [X]% |
| :warning: Unfavourable | [X] | [X]% |
| :red_circle: Heavily Unfavourable | [X] | [X]% |
| :black_circle: Missing | [X] | [X]% |

---

## Clause-by-Clause Comparison

| # | Clause | Your Position | Market Standard | Deviation | Rating |
|---|--------|--------------|-----------------|-----------|--------|
| 1 | [clause name] | [summary of contract's position] | [market benchmark] | [+2/0/-1/-2] | [:white_check_mark:/:large_blue_circle:/:warning:/:red_circle:/:black_circle:] |
| 2 | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |
| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |

---

## :red_circle: Heavily Unfavourable Clauses

### [Clause Name]
- **Your Position:** [what the contract says]
- **Market Standard:** [what market-standard terms would say]
- **Risk:** [specific risk this creates for you]
- **Recommended Position:** [what to negotiate for]
- **Negotiation Leverage:** [suggested approach]

[Repeat for each Heavily Unfavourable clause]

---

## :warning: Unfavourable Clauses

### [Clause Name]
- **Your Position:** [what the contract says]
- **Market Standard:** [what market-standard terms would say]
- **Risk:** [specific risk]
- **Recommended Position:** [what to negotiate for]

[Repeat for each Unfavourable clause]

---

## :black_circle: Missing Clauses

### [Clause Name]
- **Why This Matters:** [explanation of the risk created by omission]
- **Market Standard:** [what would typically be included]
- **Recommended Addition:** [suggested clause summary]

[Repeat for each Missing clause]

---

## :white_check_mark: Favourable Clauses

| # | Clause | Summary | Benefit |
|---|--------|---------|---------|
| 1 | [clause] | [position] | [why this is favourable] |
| ... | ... | ... | ... |

---

## :large_blue_circle: Market Standard Clauses

| # | Clause | Summary |
|---|--------|---------|
| 1 | [clause] | [position matches market] |
| ... | ... | ... |

---

## Renegotiation Priorities

### P1 - Immediate (Address Before Signing)

| # | Clause | Current Position | Target Position | Risk if Unchanged |
|---|--------|-----------------|-----------------|-------------------|
| 1 | [clause] | [current] | [target] | [risk] |
| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |

### P2 - High (Negotiate Strongly)

| # | Clause | Current Position | Target Position | Impact |
|---|--------|-----------------|-----------------|--------|
| 1 | [clause] | [current] | [target] | [impact] |
| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |

### P3 - Medium (Request Changes)

| # | Clause | Current Position | Suggested Improvement |
|---|--------|-----------------|----------------------|
| 1 | [clause] | [current] | [improvement] |
| ... | ... | ... | ... |

### P4 - Low (Nice to Have)

| # | Clause | Note |
|---|--------|------|
| 1 | [clause] | [note] |
| ... | ... | ... |

---

## Contract Favourability Summary

**Overall Assessment:** [Balanced / Slightly Favourable / Slightly Unfavourable / Heavily One-Sided]

[2-4 sentence summary of the contract's overall position relative to market, identifying the most significant areas of concern and strength, and a practical recommendation on whether to sign, negotiate, or walk away.]

**Key Strengths:**
1. [strength 1]
2. [strength 2]
3. [strength 3]

**Key Concerns:**
1. [concern 1]
2. [concern 2]
3. [concern 3]

**Recommendation:** [Sign as-is / Sign with minor amendments / Negotiate before signing / Seek legal advice before proceeding / Do not sign without material renegotiation]

---

## Limitations of This Review

- This review evaluates the content of the submitted document only
- Market benchmarks are based on general market practice and may not reflect specific industry norms, deal dynamics, or the relative bargaining power of the parties
- Benchmark positions may vary by sector, transaction size, and commercial context
- This review does not assess the enforceability of specific clauses under the laws of England and Wales
- Restrictive covenant enforceability depends on the specific facts and the doctrine of restraint of trade
- This review does not replace professional legal advice from a qualified solicitor
- Scoring is indicative and should not be used as the sole basis for commercial decisions
- This tool is designed for use under the laws of England and Wales; contracts governed by other jurisdictions may have different market norms

---

Phase 5: Present to User

After generating the report:

1. Display the Market Benchmark Score prominently with the overall assessment
2. Show the score distribution (count of Favourable / Market Standard / Unfavourable / Heavily Unfavourable / Missing)
3. Highlight the top 3 most concerning clauses with one-line plain English explanations
4. State the overall contract favourability assessment
5. Show the full report
6. Offer: "Would you like me to generate specific renegotiation language for any of these clauses? Identify the clauses and run /legal negotiate <file>."
7. Offer: "Would you like me to do a full legal risk review of this contract? Run /legal review <file>."