Long run

Long Run — autonomous multi-agent build orchestrator

Distilled from a working pattern (weekend SDK + monorepo build, 14+ milestones, file-based state, /loop-driven). Build the harness; the user owns the kickoff.

Operating model

• One orchestrator, many workers. A /loop cycle re-fires every N minutes. Each cycle the orchestrator picks the next eligible milestone, spawns a worker via the Agent tool, runs gates, merges (or files a block), updates state, exits the turn.
• State on disk, not in conversation. Everything that matters across cycles lives in .agents/STATE.md, .agents/DIGEST.md, .agents/BLOCKED.md. The orchestrator is stateless between cycles and reconstructs from these files every time.
• Git is the source of truth. Workers branch, commit, open PRs, squash-merge. The diff is the artifact. No deployments, no force pushes.
• Roadmap is gospel. Never invent milestones; only execute them.
• One repo, one prototype. App, docs, marketing, tests, screenshots all colocated so a single PR can update related surfaces atomically.

Hard prerequisites

Do not proceed to scaffolding until ALL are true. If any is missing, engage the user.

1. Git repository. test -d .git.
2. Detailed roadmap at .agents/ROADMAP.md (or equivalent) with explicit per-milestone:
   • id (e.g. M0, P2.1)
   • dependencies (other milestone ids)
   • contract (exact allowed-paths whitelist)
   • DoD (verifiable bullets, not "make it good")
   • model + subagent type
3. Source-of-truth docs in repo for the surfaces in scope:
   • DESIGN.md if UI work is in scope
   • VOICE.md if user-facing copy is in scope
   • architecture doc if SDK/library work is in scope
4. Quality gates wired up. A single command that runs typecheck + lint + test + build. Workers must pass it before merge.
5. Deny-list in .claude/settings.local.json blocking deploy commands and force-push.
6. .agents/STOP convention as kill switch.

Phase 1 — Pre-flight audit

Run the audit. Report each as ✓ or ✗.

echo "--- long-run pre-flight ---"
test -d .git && echo "✓ git repo" || echo "✗ not a git repo"
git remote -v | grep -q . && echo "✓ git remote configured" || echo "⚠ no git remote (PR flow falls back to local squash-merge)"
for f in .agents/ROADMAP.md .agents/orchestrator-prompt.md .agents/STATE.md .agents/DIGEST.md .agents/BLOCKED.md; do
  test -f "$f" && echo "✓ $f" || echo "✗ $f"
done
test -f .claude/settings.local.json && grep -q '"deny"' .claude/settings.local.json && echo "✓ deny list" || echo "✗ no deny list"
test -f DESIGN.md && echo "• DESIGN.md present" || echo "• DESIGN.md absent (required if UI in scope)"
test -f VOICE.md && echo "• VOICE.md present" || echo "• VOICE.md absent (required if copy in scope)"

If the audit fails on git, stop entirely. If it fails only on harness files, that's expected — Phase 3 scaffolds them. If the roadmap is missing, jump to Phase 2.

Phase 2 — Roadmap engagement (only if missing or incomplete)

Do not auto-generate the roadmap. It encodes the user's product decisions and the orchestrator treats it as gospel — generating it without user buy-in poisons the entire run.

Ask the user:

A long-running orchestrator needs a detailed milestone plan before kickoff. What do you have?

• A) I have a roadmap doc — let me point you at it
• B) I have a high-level idea but no milestone plan
• C) I haven't thought through the project yet

If A: ask the path, read it, audit against the per-milestone schema (id, deps, contract, DoD, model). For each missing field, ask the user to fill it in OR offer to draft a candidate they review. Do not silently fill gaps.

If B or C: stop the skill. Tell the user:

A long-running build needs an approved spec. Brainstorm the problem first (e.g. via /office-hours or your team's equivalent), then lock in architecture (e.g. via /plan-eng-review), then come back. Generating a plan unprompted would burn cycles on the wrong work — that call belongs upstream.

When extending a partial spec into per-milestone contracts, for each milestone confirm:

• id + human title
• dependencies (which milestones must finish first)
• allowed-paths whitelist — exact globs the worker may touch (drives the contract-violation check)
• DoD bullets — verifiable, concrete (tests pass, file exists, screenshot committed, coverage ≥ N%)
• which surfaces this touches (sdk / app / docs / marketing) — drives colocation expectations
• model + subagent_type

Rule of thumb: if a one-line shell test cannot verify the DoD, it's not concrete enough.

Phase 3 — Scaffold the harness (only after the roadmap is locked)

Read the templates bundled with this skill at references/templates/ and write them into the repo, substituting {{placeholders}} interactively:

• references/templates/orchestrator-prompt.md → .agents/orchestrator-prompt.md
• references/templates/STATE.md → .agents/STATE.md
• references/templates/DIGEST.md → .agents/DIGEST.md
• references/templates/BLOCKED.md → .agents/BLOCKED.md
• references/templates/settings.local.json → .claude/settings.local.json (merge if exists)
• references/templates/ROADMAP-skeleton.md → starting point if the user is hand-authoring

Required substitutions in the orchestrator prompt (ask the user, don't guess):

• {{project-name}}
• {{gate-command}} — single shell command that runs typecheck + lint + test + build for the whole project (e.g. pnpm turbo run typecheck lint test build --concurrency=1)
• {{source-of-truth-docs}} — list of docs the orchestrator reads each cycle (DESIGN.md, VOICE.md, architecture doc, etc.)
• {{merge-strategy}} — gh pr create + gh pr merge --squash (default, requires remote) OR local squash-merge to main (no remote)
• {{notification-block}} — paste the Slack block from references/templates/notify-slack.md if the user wants notifications; otherwise replace with "skip notification".
• {{rate-limit-policy}} — default is "write to BLOCKED.md, end turn, next /loop fire retries"

Add to .gitignore:

.agents/STOP

Commit the harness:

git add .agents/ .claude/settings.local.json .gitignore
git commit -m "chore: scaffold long-run orchestrator harness"

Phase 4 — Asset colocation check

The prototype's app, docs, marketing, tests, and screenshots must live in this repo so they evolve together. Audit the layout:

ls -d apps/* packages/* docs/ marketing/ 2>/dev/null
find . -maxdepth 3 -name 'DESIGN.md' -o -name 'VOICE.md' -o -name '*-architecture.md' 2>/dev/null | grep -v node_modules

Common shapes that work:

• Monorepo (SDK + apps): packages/<lib>/, apps/<app>/, top-level DESIGN.md / VOICE.md / architecture doc, .agents/screenshots/<milestone>/.
• Single app: src/, docs/, optional marketing/, tests/, .agents/screenshots/<milestone>/.

If the user keeps assets elsewhere (Notion docs, Webflow marketing, Figma-only design), flag this:

The orchestrator can only update files in this repo. {{asset}} lives outside it, so the build can't keep it in sync. Bring it into the repo (even as a stub) or accept that {{asset}} will drift.

Phase 5 — Safety rails

Walk through each. Confirm before kickoff.

1. Third-party API spend caps. Any runtime API key used by the demo (Anthropic, OpenAI, etc.) should be a dedicated key with a hard workspace spend cap. Workers cannot exceed what the key allows.
2. Pre-push hook at .git/hooks/pre-push running the full gate command. Optional but recommended — catches regressions before they hit the remote.
3. Mac wake-lock. In a separate terminal: caffeinate -dimsu &. If the machine sleeps, /loop dies silently and hours of cycles are lost. Do not swap /loop for launchd, cron, or a remote routine "for resilience" — you lose live visibility and headless claude -p has known toolchain traps (see Known traps #1, #4).
4. Kill switch test.

   touch .agents/STOP && ls .agents/STOP && rm .agents/STOP
   

5. Notification channel (if configured) — confirm the orchestrator can reach it before kickoff.

Phase 6 — Kickoff

Tell the user — do not run this yourself:

/loop 45m act as the orchestrator per .agents/orchestrator-prompt.md

Default interval: 45 minutes (balances Anthropic rate-limit recovery against forward progress). 60 minutes is also fine for smaller cycles. Avoid <30 minutes — rate windows get squeezed.

Final words to the user:

• Walk away. Check back periodically via STATE.md and DIGEST.md.
• To stop early: touch .agents/STOP. Resume with rm .agents/STOP then re-issue the /loop command.
• Read order on return: BLOCKED.md → DIGEST.md → recent PRs → STATE.md.

Hard rules for this skill

• Never invoke /loop yourself. This skill builds the harness; the user kicks off.
• Never auto-generate the roadmap. If missing, route the user upstream and stop.
• Never commit without showing the user the harness files first. They are about to delegate authority to an orchestrator — they need to see what it will do.
• Never push to main from this skill. All commits are local; the user pushes manually.

Known traps (from real runs)

Each of these cost time on a real autonomous build. The templates this skill ships now encode the fix; the explanations live here so future maintainers know why the templates look the way they do.

Trap 1 — Headless orchestrator hides its work

What goes wrong: Setting up the orchestrator via launchd, cron, or a remote routine "for resilience" sounds smart, but claude -p running non-interactively writes nothing useful to stdout / stderr. The only live view is the JSONL session log under ~/.claude/projects/<repo>/, which is awkward to follow with jq and easy to miss when a worker turn goes sideways. You can't catch a bad turn until after it lands on main.

The fix: Run the orchestrator in an attended /loop in your interactive terminal. Use caffeinate for the wake-lock. Accept that if the session dies (laptop sleeps without caffeinate, terminal closes), the cycle dies — that's the trade. The visibility is worth it.

If you genuinely need unattended overnight: wrap claude -p in launchd, but verify the MCP toolchain works headless first (Trap 4) and accept that you'll be reading DIGEST.md + JSONL after the fact rather than watching live.

Trap 2 — Bookkeeping carried across cycles

What goes wrong: Cycle N updates STATE.md or DIGEST.md but doesn't commit before spawning the worker. Cycle N+1 inherits the dirty working tree. A git stash somewhere — to give the worker a clean checkout — drops uncommitted bookkeeping into a dangling stash. Hours later, "where did cycle 19's DIGEST entry go?" becomes real archeology.

The fix: The orchestrator-prompt.md template now requires the orchestrator to commit STATE.md / DIGEST.md atomically at every meaningful checkpoint (dispatch, worker return, gates pass, block), not at end-of-cycle. This makes recovery from a crashed cycle trivial: the next cycle just reads the committed state. Push them directly to main as chore: orchestrator cycle N — <outcome> (see Trap 5 — the "never push to main" rule is carved out for bookkeeping).

Trap 3 — BLOCKED entries without a decision tree

What goes wrong: A worker reports an issue, the orchestrator dumps a paragraph to BLOCKED.md, the cycle ends. When the human comes back — potentially days later — they have to re-derive: what specifically failed, what was already tried, what are the realistic options, what does each cost? Context decay turns a 10-minute decision into an afternoon.

The fix: The BLOCKED.md template now requires every entry to carry four parts: symptom (exact failure), what was tried (one attempted fix and why it didn't work), options forward (2–3 paths with cost / risk / reversibility), and recommended path (the orchestrator's pick + reasoning). If the orchestrator can't fill all four, the entry should say so explicitly — that itself is information.

Trap 4 — Headless MCP tool surprises

What goes wrong: Interactive Claude sessions auto-resolve a wide range of MCP tools (Slack, Linear, Notion, etc.). claude -p in headless / launchd / remote-routine contexts often ships with a narrower default toolset; deferred MCP tools need an explicit ToolSearch round-trip to load. A Slack notification step that "works in dev" silently no-ops in production.

The fix: If notifications matter, test them from a non-interactive Claude session (claude -p "use the Slack MCP to send a test message") before kickoff. The notify-slack.md template now flags this. If the headless path doesn't load the tool, either add an explicit ToolSearch step to the orchestrator-prompt or treat DIGEST.md as the only reliable heartbeat and drop the notification.

Trap 5 — "Never push to main" is too broad

What goes wrong: A blanket "never push to main" rule is correct for milestone code (which flows through PR + squash merge) but wrong for orchestrator bookkeeping. STATE.md and DIGEST.md updates fire every cycle; routing them through PRs is bureaucratic theater, and not pushing them means cross-machine continuity breaks.

The fix: The orchestrator-prompt.md template now carves out an exception:

Never push code to main. STATE.md, DIGEST.md, and BLOCKED.md updates may be pushed directly to main as chore: orchestrator cycle N — <outcome>.

---

Completion

Report status using one of:

• DONE — harness scaffolded, roadmap locked, safety rails confirmed, kickoff command in the user's hands.
• DONE_WITH_CONCERNS — kickoff is possible but specific risks were flagged (list them).
• BLOCKED — missing roadmap, no git, or a fundamental gap that needs human work first.
• NEEDS_CONTEXT — waiting on user input.