Critique

Skill raven-sourav/pmm-content-engine/skills/critique

PMM Content Distribution Engine — Newsletter scraper, Obsidian knowledge brain, multi-format content generation powered by Claude Code

Install

npx -y skills add raven-sourav/pmm-content-engine --skill critique

Assembled from the repository path, not quoted from the project. Check it against their README if it does not work.

2 things to look at

no licenseNo license file was found in the repository. Code published without one is not open source by default, so using it at work is a question for whoever answers licensing questions where you are.
3 stars3 stars. Stars are a popularity signal and not a quality one, but at this level it is likely that nobody has read this closely except its author, and you would be relying on your own review.

SKILL.md

1.7 KB, as published. Nobody here has run it

Skill: Critique a Draft

Trigger

User submits a draft for critique, or critique runs as part of generation.

Process

Step 1: Load references

Always load: references/rubber-duck-escalator.md
Load for voice check: data/brain/pmm_brain.json (voice_profile_sourav, quality_bar_examples)

Step 2: Run 5 phases sequentially

Each phase sees the draft + all prior phase results:

MIRROR — Is this lived experience or knowledge-reporting?
PROBE — What uncomfortable truth is being dodged?
CHALLENGE — Where is the logic soft? Evidence check.
ILLUMINATE — What threads haven't been connected?
CRYSTALLIZE — Does it sound like Sourav specifically?

Step 3: Score and gate

Score each phase 1-10 (critique first, score based on own critique)
All 5 must be 8+ to pass
If any < 8: provide specific rewrite instructions
If composite < 4.0: flag for fundamental rethinking

Step 4: Present scorecard

Show phase-by-phase results with specific line references.

Output Format

━━━━ RUBBER DUCK SCORECARD ━━━━

MIRROR:      [score]/10 — [one-line summary]
PROBE:       [score]/10 — [one-line summary]
CHALLENGE:   [score]/10 — [one-line summary]
ILLUMINATE:  [score]/10 — [one-line summary]
CRYSTALLIZE: [score]/10 — [one-line summary]

COMPOSITE: [score] | STATUS: [PASS/REWRITE/FLAG]

[If REWRITE: specific instructions ranked by severity]
[If FLAG: what needs fundamental rethinking]

See also: skills/generate/ (produces drafts for critique) | references/rubber-duck-escalator.md (full protocol)

See also: skills/generate/ (revision loop with critique) | references/rubber-duck-escalator.md (full protocol) | skills/_index.md for full data flow