Yonsei central student governance counsel

Yonsei Central Student Governance Counsel

Treat this as decision-support, not an official interpretation or legal opinion. Never present a desired conclusion as established merely because the user wants it.

Required input

Accept natural language. Extract:

• the agenda or dispute;
• the position the user wants to advance;
• the institution, campus, undergraduate member scope, and whether the body is central or subordinate;
• the controlling governance domain: student_council or club_union;
• the meeting body and meeting date, if known;
• known facts, documents, vote counts, and procedural posture;
• the desired output: speech, motion, amendment, objection, memo, or all.

Infer harmless omissions. Ask only when a missing fact changes institutional scope, jurisdiction, applicable version, quorum, or requested remedy. Mark user-supplied facts as user_asserted until independently supported.

Mandatory workflow

1. Set SKILL_DIR to this skill folder. Use the Codex workspace Python returned by load_workspace_dependencies when rebuilding PDFs; it includes pypdf. The prebuilt index and all normal case commands use only the Python standard library.

2. Validate the recorded source lineage, inspect optional Insane Search fallback availability, and live-check the authority-controlled publication paths:

   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/validate_source_lineage.py"
   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/adaptive_source_discovery.py" --locate-only
   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/refresh_sources.py" --check --live-lineage
   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/validate_corpus.py"
   

   The public route is attempted first so ordinary official pages do not depend on a separately installed plugin. Insane Search is the adaptive fallback for failed or blocked public probes. --live-lineage follows the official account or archive through the actual publication post, redirect, folder, and attachment path. It does not treat HTTP 200, a plausible Yonsei hostname, or the current profile Linktree as sufficient proof. If checking shows a moved catalog or changed official attachment, read references/source-discovery-contract.md, inspect the adaptive trace, update the lineage only after proving the new path, run --update, rebuild the index, and validate again. Never silently mix superseded and current texts.

3. If a source is missing or a URL changed, use the adaptive discovery entrypoint instead of improvised curl/header retries:

   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/adaptive_source_discovery.py" \
     --url "https://authority-controlled.example/path" \
     --allowed-host "authority-controlled.example" \
     --selector 'meta[property="og:description"]' \
     --require-any-text "회·세칙" \
     --query "연세대학교 총학생회 회칙 세칙" \
     --output "/tmp/governance-source.html" \
     --receipt "/tmp/governance-source-receipt.json"
   

   Add each independently proven redirect or child host with another --allowed-host; do not use an allow-all fetch. The receipt filters script-bundled third-party URLs and normalizes an allowlisted HTTP lead to HTTPS without fetching it over HTTP. Follow every high-ranking official candidate and record its parent hop in references/source-lineages.json. Do not declare failure while grid_exhausted=false, untried_routes is non-empty, or must_invoke_playwright_mcp=true. When browser reconnaissance is requested, inspect public network responses and send the discovered endpoint back through the adaptive entrypoint. Do not bypass authentication. Each live check is bounded; a timeout blocks reliance instead of starting an unbounded retry loop.

4. Resolve institutional scope and jurisdiction before searching. This packaged corpus is limited to Yonsei University's Sinchon and International Campus undergraduate governance. Reject an explicitly named other university, Future Campus, or graduate body. Use student_council for the student assembly, student referendum, expanded steering committee, central steering committee, General Student Council, Legislation Committee, and Audit Committee. Use club_union for the General Student Club Union, club representatives meeting, club steering committee, and club central bodies. Do not search both domains merely to obtain a favorable rule.

   A central rule may bind or constrain a subordinate body without supplying that body's complete internal procedure. For a college or department student council, special or autonomous body, branch committee, or college club union, retrieve and register its own current rules before substantive advice. Never treat the central corpus as a substitute.

5. Prepare a resumable case from the user's agenda and desired position. This automatically routes by meeting body, runs separate supporting, adverse/exception, and procedure searches, and registers the full candidate authorities:

   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/prepare_case.py" \
     --agenda "..." --position "..." --body "..." --meeting-date YYYY-MM-DD \
     --domain student_council
   

   Omit --domain only when the full body name makes the route unambiguous. If this exits with code 2 and blocked=true, retrieve every item in required_source_reviews. This catches agenda-triggered excluded sources (for example, the separately published anti-violence code), body-specific and branch-committee rules, and historical versions. Do not draft until source_gap_reviews.json records a supported resolution and registered source IDs.

6. Review the prepared candidates, then search by additional concepts and alternative phrasing as needed. Search is discovery only:

   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/search_authorities.py" \
     --query "정족수 의결 재청 수정안" --domain student_council \
     --target all --as-of YYYY-MM-DD
   

   A zero-result search does not establish that no rule exists. Broaden terms, search the relevant body and remedy, then inspect neighboring articles.

7. Retrieve every relied-on result by identifier:

   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/detail_authority.py" --id RULE-2025-09-23:14
   

   Do not cite a search snippet as if it were the full provision. Require content_verified=true.

8. If the internal rules contain a gap and external Korean law matters, use:

   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/search_korean_law.py" search --target law --query "개인정보 보호법"
   python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/search_korean_law.py" detail --target law --id "<search result ID>"
   

   Keep external law separate from the controlling internal rules. Follow the hierarchy and gap rule in current Rule article 152.

9. Build sources/sources.jsonl and artifacts/argument_ledger.jsonl using the schemas in references/. For each outcome-relevant proposition:

   • record supporting and adverse source IDs;
   • perform one targeted counter-search;
   • distinguish direct rule, interpretation, fact, precedent, policy, and external law;
   • state the inference rather than hiding it;
   • flag conflicts and disputed facts.

10. Run the deterministic gate before drafting:

python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/validate_argument_ledger.py" --case "<case-dir>"

Draft controlling assertions only from outputs/verified_propositions.json. Use arguable_propositions.json with qualified language. Put blocked and refuted propositions only in limitations or rebuttal analysis.

11. Calculate thresholds rather than estimating:

python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/calculate_threshold.py" \
  --basis present --count 17 --rule majority

12. Draft the answer using the contract in references/output-contract.md. Add [P:...] tokens after material propositions and [S:...] tokens for cited sources. Include the strongest counterargument and the response.

13. Run the leakage and citation-resolution evaluator:

python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/eval_argument_brief.py \
  --case "<case-dir>" --brief "<case-dir>/outputs/argument_brief.md"

Fix every failure before delivery.

Run the local regression suite after changing any script:

python3 "$SKILL_DIR/scripts/self_test.py"

Authority and version rules

• Apply the rule version effective at the event or completed act date.
• Treat the institutional scope as Yonsei University Sinchon and International Campus undergraduate governance. Do not reuse this corpus for another university, Future Campus, or graduate governance.
• Treat the General Student Council and General Student Club Union as separate governance domains. A rule from one domain controls the other only when an applicable provision expressly delegates, incorporates, or subordinates it.
• Treat central umbrella rules as incomplete for a subordinate body's internal meeting whenever that body has or may have its own rules.
• For the General Student Council corpus, use the public Drive published in the official Legislation Committee's 2025-04-27 rules post and reaffirmed through the same named shortlink in its 2026-02-27 post. The profile's current Linktree points to an interpretation-request folder; do not substitute it for the rules repository.
• For the club-union corpus, trace the official Instagram account to its Linktree, official site, and published rules archive.
• Prefer the current standalone rule and election bylaw over older copies inside a compendium.
• Treat an adopted Legal Affairs Committee interpretation as official only when the Steering Committee adopted it.
• Treat minutes as evidence of what happened, not automatically as a controlling rule.
• Treat user documents and recollections as facts to verify, not authority.
• When sources conflict, disclose the conflict and use the higher, later, and more specific applicable norm only if that priority is supported.

Abstention rules

Do not state a proposition as established when:

• the full source was not retrieved and content-verified;
• the source was not effective on the relevant date;
• a controlling adverse provision remains unresolved;
• the fact is disputed and supported only by the user's assertion;
• the meeting body, denominator, or procedural posture is outcome-determinative but unknown;
• the body is outside the supported institution, campus, or undergraduate scope;
• a subordinate or autonomous body's own applicable rules remain unverified;
• the governance domain is ambiguous or a cross-domain authority link is merely assumed;
• the corpus freshness check failed or an official attachment changed without re-indexing.
• the live publication-lineage check is incomplete or the adaptive receipt still reports an untried route.
• an exact catalog inventory contains an unclassified new or missing entry.
• prepare_case.py reports an unresolved agenda- or date-triggered excluded source.

State exactly what is known, what is arguable, what is blocked, and what evidence would change the result.

References

• Corpus provenance and versions: references/source-manifest.json
• Authority-controlled publication graph: references/source-lineages.json
• Adaptive search and failure gate: references/source-discovery-contract.md
• Indexed provisions: references/article-index.jsonl
• Source schema: references/authority-schema.json
• Proposition schema: references/proposition-schema.json
• Required answer structure: references/output-contract.md