Autoiter

collie:autoiter — Main Autoiter Orchestrator

Drives the iterative improvement pipeline: run trigger → observe → triage → deep-verify → gated fix → rerun → stop check. Invoked by commands/autoiter.md on every ralph-loop session restart.

Completion signal: <promise>Collie: AUTOITER DONE</promise> Sentinel rule: Emitted ONLY by the §3.5 terminal branch. NO other stage emits it inline.

---

Flowchart

digraph autoiter {
  rankdir=TB;
  node [shape=box, style=rounded];
  entry [label="SKILL entry\n§3.5 state machine"];
  nested_check [label="Nested-call check\n(COLLIE_AUTOITER_ACTIVE?)"];
  fail_fast [label="fail-fast escalate\n(do NOT rm current-run)", shape=ellipse];
  no_current_run [label="current-run missing?", shape=diamond];
  fresh_start [label="Fresh start:\ngenerate runId\nwrite current-run"];
  stage0 [label="Stage 0\nDiscovery & Lock\n(planmode)"];
  ralph_restart [label="ExitPlanMode\n→ ralph-loop restart"];
  run_spec_missing [label="run-spec.md missing?", shape=diamond];
  recovery [label="Recovery chain:\nlast-plan.json→plan file\n→plan-source→cp run-spec.md"];
  recovery_fail [label="Recovery failed\nrm current-run", shape=ellipse];
  worktree_prepare [label="Create worktree\nautoiter-prepare (if needed)\ninit state.json(iter=1)"];
  read_state [label="Read state.json"];
  terminal [label="status=terminal:\nrm current-run\nemit sentinel", shape=ellipse];
  stage1 [label="Stage 1 Kickoff"];
  stage2 [label="Stage 2 Run Trigger\n(background)"];
  stage3 [label="Stage 3 Observe"];
  blocker [label="Blocking issue?\nauto-recovery ladder", shape=diamond];
  blocker_fail [label="Write escalated → return\n(§3.5 handles)", shape=ellipse];
  stage4a [label="Stage 4a Triage\n(opus, reverse suspicion)"];
  stage4b [label="Stage 4b Deep Verify\n(opus, adversarial, parallel)"];
  stage50 [label="Stage 5.0 Fix Plan\n(G7 check first)"];
  g7_fail [label="G7 deadlock\nescalated → return", shape=ellipse];
  stage51 [label="Stage 5.1 flow"];
  stage52 [label="Stage 5.2 G6 Diff Audit"];
  g6_fail [label="G6 fail\nescalated → return", shape=ellipse];
  stage53 [label="Stage 5.3 Rerun + scalar"];
  stage6 [label="Stage 6 Rollback + Stop Check"];
  stop [label="Stop: write terminal state\nreturn (§3.5 handles sentinel)", shape=ellipse];
  next_iter [label="iter++\nstate=running → Stage 1"];

  entry -> nested_check;
  nested_check -> fail_fast [label="COLLIE_AUTOITER_ACTIVE set"];
  nested_check -> no_current_run [label="not nested"];
  no_current_run -> fresh_start [label="yes"];
  no_current_run -> run_spec_missing [label="no"];
  fresh_start -> stage0;
  stage0 -> ralph_restart;
  ralph_restart -> entry [label="next session §3.5 re-entry"];
  run_spec_missing -> recovery [label="yes"];
  recovery -> recovery_fail [label="chain fails"];
  recovery_fail -> fresh_start [label="fresh start"];
  recovery -> worktree_prepare [label="success"];
  worktree_prepare -> stage1;
  run_spec_missing -> read_state [label="no"];
  read_state -> stage1 [label="status=running"];
  read_state -> stage6 [label="status=iter_done"];
  read_state -> terminal [label="status=terminal"];
  stage1 -> stage2;
  stage2 -> stage3;
  stage3 -> blocker;
  blocker -> stage4a [label="no blocking issues"];
  blocker -> blocker_fail [label="ladder exhausted"];
  stage4a -> stage4b;
  stage4b -> stage50;
  stage50 -> g7_fail [label="G7 deadlock"];
  stage50 -> stage51 [label="ok"];
  stage51 -> stage52;
  stage52 -> g6_fail [label="audit FAIL"];
  stage52 -> stage53 [label="PASS"];
  stage53 -> stage6;
  stage6 -> stop [label="SC1-SC5 met"];
  stage6 -> next_iter [label="continue"];
  next_iter -> stage1;
}

---

Section 0 — Orchestrator Contract（必读，约束所有 stage）

⛔ 主 session 是协调器，不是执行器。

主 session 禁止做的事

• ❌ 读项目源代码（src 文件）
• ❌ grep / find / 全文搜索项目代码（除单点 hash/scalar 提取）
• ❌ 写实现代码 / 修复代码
• ❌ 解析 > 50 行日志
• ❌ inline 执行 git revert / git reset --hard 实质操作

主 session 必须做的事

• ✅ 决策（基于 subagent 输出）
• ✅ dispatch 子 agent + 状态文件读写
• ✅ 写 status.md / progress.md / fix-plan.md（汇总 subagent 输出）
• ✅ 触发外部命令（trigger / rerun bash 启动）但不解析 stdout

主 session 例外项（明文允许 inline）

仅以下 5 类操作允许 inline，逻辑上是单点动作：

1. Stage 2 nohup bash 启动 trigger（单行命令）
2. Stage 5.0 写 fix-plan.md（仅汇总 4b deep-verify 输出，禁止读源码）
3. Stage 5.2 git diff HEAD~1..HEAD --name-only（单行 git，结果不解析）
4. 状态文件 IO（~/.collie/autoiter/... 下的 status / progress / state）
5. iter 边界的目录创建（mkdir -p iter-N/）

Subagent 派发裁定基准（主 agent 自主裁定，不在 plan 硬编码）

每次需要执行操作时，主 agent 按以下基准自主裁定 inline vs dispatch + model：

裁定步骤：

1. 此步是"决策"还是"执行"？决策 inline，执行 dispatch
2. 输入是否会污染主 agent 上下文（log / source code / 大返回）？是 → dispatch
3. 选 model：参考用户 ~/.claude/CLAUDE.md 中的"Agent 模型选择速查"+"Subagent 派发策略"两节

Agent 模型选择速查（节选自用户 CLAUDE.md）：

• Explore → haiku（文件搜索、代码分析、只读探索）
• general-purpose 轻量 → haiku（文档生成、简单分析）
• general-purpose 标准 → sonnet（代码实现、中等复杂度）
• general-purpose 复杂 → opus（架构决策、复杂重构）
• code-reviewer → sonnet
• Plan → opus（架构设计、规划）

典型应用例子（参考，非强制；具体 stage 由主 agent 实时裁定）：

• 应用 fix patch 到 worktree → 实现型 → dispatch sonnet
• 解析 raw.log 提 scalar → 文档/分析型 → dispatch haiku
• 写 fix-plan.md 综合 → 决策型 → inline（受 §例外项 #2 约束）
• 跑 git revert + verify hash → 执行型 → dispatch haiku
• Triage / Deep Verify → 复杂推理型 → dispatch opus（这是历史不变式，contract test 强制）

历史不变式（contract test 强制保留）

• Stage 4a/4b（Triage / Deep Verify）必须保持 opus subagent，不可降为 inline 或更低 model
• Stage 5.0 fix-plan 必须保持 inline 但受 §例外项 #2 约束

任何其他 stage 的 inline / dispatch + model 选择由主 agent 实时裁定，plan 不硬编码。

---

§3.5 Entry State Machine (FIRST thing executed every session)

Setup

PROJECT_ID=$(node -e "const s=require('./hooks/_state.js'); console.log(s.projectId())")
CURRENT_RUN_FILE=$(node -e "const s=require('./hooks/_state.js'); console.log(s.currentRunFile('$PROJECT_ID'))")

Nested-call check

If COLLIE_AUTOITER_ACTIVE environment variable is set → this is a nested call from inside another /auto or /autoiter session.

Action: call scripts/escalate.sh "nested_loop_call" "$PROJECT_ID" then stop immediately. Do NOT rm current-run (the outer run owns it).

If not nested: set export COLLIE_AUTOITER_ACTIVE=1 for all subprocesses in this session, then proceed.

Branch A — No current-run file

~/.collie/autoiter/{project-id}/current-run does NOT exist → Fresh start:

1. Generate runId: YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS-{shortSessionId} (use date +%Y%m%d-%H%M%S + first 6 chars of $CLAUDE_SESSION_ID or random hex)
2. mkdir -p ~/.collie/autoiter/{project-id}/
3. Write runId to current-run file
4. Proceed to Stage 0

Branch B — current-run exists, run-spec.md does NOT exist

Post-planmode recovery path:

1. runId = $(cat $CURRENT_RUN_FILE)
2. Attempt recovery chain:
   • Read ~/.collie/state/{sessionId}/last-plan.json → get plan file path
   • Read first 3 lines of plan file → extract plan-source field value
   • If recovery chain fails at any step → rm $CURRENT_RUN_FILE → go to Branch A
3. Recovery succeeded:

   mkdir -p ~/.collie/autoiter/{project-id}/{runId}/
   # ⛔ NEVER use Write or Edit — cp only (prevents LLM rewriting content)
   cp "$PLAN_SOURCE" ~/.collie/autoiter/{project-id}/{runId}/run-spec.md
   git worktree add .worktrees/autoiter-{runId} -b autoiter/{runId}
   echo "$(pwd)/.worktrees/autoiter-{runId}" > ~/.collie/autoiter/{project-id}/{runId}/worktree-path
   

4. Read skip_prepare from run-spec.md
5. If skip_prepare=false AND prepare-report.md does NOT exist:
   • Call Skill('collie:autoiter-prepare') with: run_spec_path, report_path, project_id, run_id, worktree_path
   • PASS → continue
   • FAIL (interactive): AskUserQuestion "Prepare failed: [X]. Fix material and retry, or abort?"
   • FAIL (queued): write state.json.status="escalated" → return (§3.5 terminal handles on next restart)
6. Initialize state.json:

   {
     "runId": "<runId>",
     "iter": 1,
     "status": "running",
     "should_continue": true,
     "stop_reason": null,
     "last_scalar": null,
     "baseline_scalar": null,
     "promise_signal": "Collie: AUTOITER DONE"
   }
   

7. Proceed to Stage 1

Branch C — current-run AND run-spec.md exist

Read state.json:

status	action
"running"	Re-enter Stage 1 kickoff (idempotent: skip write if kickoff.md already exists)
"iter_done"	Proceed to Stage 6 stop check
"converged" / "budget_exhausted" / "escalated"	Terminal: rm current-run → print [autoiter {runId}] All done — status={status} → emit <promise>Collie: AUTOITER DONE</promise> → stop
missing	Treat same as Branch B (run-spec.md missing path)

---

Stage 0 — Discovery & Lock (planmode)

Only reached on fresh start from Branch A.

Step 0.1 — Enter planmode

Call EnterPlanMode.

Step 0.2 — Discovery subagent (haiku, Explore / read-only)

Dispatch haiku subagent using system prompt from skills/autoiter/references/discovery-prompt.md. Input: project root. Output:

• Ranked candidate trigger list (each: command, kind, score 1-5, rationale)
• Suggested success_criterion type (all_green / scalar_threshold / convergence_delta / custom)
• Suggested primary_goal (correctness / optimization / both)

Step 0.3 — AskUserQuestion (Q1-Q5)

Collect all 5 in one batch:

• Q1: Which trigger? (show ranked list from Discovery; allow custom)
• Q2: Success criterion type and threshold?
• Q3: primary_goal? (correctness / optimization / both)
• Q4: iter_rollback_policy? (default: kind_aware)
• Q5: Skip Stage 0.5 prepare check? (default: No)

Step 0.4 — Write run-spec to planmode plan file

Write to planmode system-prompt-specified plan file (do NOT override path). Top 3 lines must be:

<!-- plan-source: <planmode plan file absolute path> -->
<!-- plan-kind: autoiter-stage0 -->
<!-- plan-executor: collie:autoiter -->

Body YAML:

task: <user prompt verbatim>
primary_goal: <Q3>
trigger:
  kind: shell|replay|dataset
  invocation: "<shell command>"
  expected_output: "stdout stream / junit xml / custom parser"
  scalar_extraction: "<grep/regex/jq path>"
success_criterion:
  type: all_green|scalar_threshold|convergence_delta|custom
  threshold: <Q2 value>
budget:
  max_iterations: 5
  max_tokens: unlimited
  max_wallclock_min: unlimited
overfit_guards: [G1, G2, G3, G4, G5, G6, G7, G8]
iter_rollback_policy: kind_aware
skip_prepare: false

Step 0.5 — ExitPlanMode

Call ExitPlanMode. This is the ONLY exit from Stage 0.

ralph-loop restarts the session. §3.5 Branch B (recovery path) handles everything after.

---

Stage 1 — Kickoff (idempotent)

Step 0 — TaskCreate stage 锚定（每 iter 起始必做）

⛔ 每次进入 Stage 1（iteration 起始）必须先做这一步，再做原 Step 1。

1. 上一 iter 的 [iter-{N-1} stage-*] 任务先标 completed（正常结束）或 deleted（被 rollback）

2. TaskCreate 6 次建立本 iter 锚点：

   • [iter-N stage-1] Kickoff（git HEAD + baseline）
   • [iter-N stage-2] Run trigger（subprocess background + Monitor/tail）
   • [iter-N stage-3] Observe（ISSUE 收集 + auto-recovery 阶梯）
   • [iter-N stage-4] Triage + Deep Verify（4a/4b opus）
   • [iter-N stage-5] Fix Plan + flow + G6 audit + Rerun（5.0/5.1/5.2/5.3）
   • [iter-N stage-6] Rollback + Stop Check

   N 从 state.json 读取

3. TaskUpdate [iter-N stage-1] in_progress，进入原 Step 1

4. Self-anchor：长 dispatch（subagent 返回 > 200 字符或耗时 > 30s）后，主 agent 必须先 TaskList 确认当前 anchor 与 SKILL 当前 stage 一致；漂移 → STOP + escalate stage_anchor_drift。Stage 切换时 TaskUpdate 切 completed/in_progress 后再进入下一 stage。

All Stage 1+ work runs inside the worktree. Read worktree-path to get the absolute path.

WORKTREE=$(cat ~/.collie/autoiter/{project-id}/{runId}/worktree-path)
ITER_DIR=~/.collie/autoiter/{project-id}/{runId}/iter-{N}
mkdir -p $ITER_DIR/fixes

Write iter-N/kickoff.md (skip if already exists — idempotency):

# Kickoff — iter-N
git_head: <git rev-parse HEAD>
baseline_metric: <state.last_scalar or "none (first iter)">
iter_goal: <based on progress.md DEFERRED pool if iter > 1>
timestamp: <ISO-8601>

Observability:

• Overwrite status.md: iter N/M · Stage 1 · Kickoff · preparing trigger
• Append user-log.md: ## iter-N · <ts>\nKickoff. HEAD: <sha>. Baseline scalar: <val>.
• Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] iter-N Stage 1 → Kickoff

---

Stage 2 — Run Trigger

Subprocess timeout

timeout_min = min(max_wallclock_min / max_iterations, 30)
# "unlimited" in either field → use 30 min

Launch (background)

# Bash run_in_background=true
cd $WORKTREE
timeout ${timeout_min}m bash -c "<trigger.invocation>" \
  > $ITER_DIR/raw.log 2>&1
echo "EXIT_CODE:$?" >> $ITER_DIR/raw.log

Monitor detection (once per session, cache result)

ToolSearch query="select:Monitor"

Monitor available: Subscribe to stdout stream in real-time. Record observations to iter-N/raw.log.

Monitor NOT available (fallback):

• ScheduleWakeup delaySeconds=60 on each poll cycle
• On wakeup: Read last 100 lines of raw.log
• Scan for ISSUE patterns (errors, metrics)
• Loop until EXIT_CODE: line appears in raw.log

Observability:

• Overwrite status.md: iter N/M · Stage 2 · Running trigger · <elapsed>s elapsed
• Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] iter-N Stage 2 → trigger running (timeout: {timeout_min}min)

---

Stage 3 — Observe & Auto-Recovery

⚠️ 本 stage 内每次执行操作前请按 §Section 0 裁定基准选择 inline / dispatch + model。fix 应用属"执行"型，参考速查表选 sonnet。

Step 3.1 — Write observations.md

Parse raw.log. For each issue:

## ISSUE-{nnn}
- title: <one-line summary>
- evidence: <log excerpt, max 5 lines>
- severity: 1-5
- first_seen_ts: <monotonic>
- blocking: true|false

Non-blocking issues → record and continue to Stage 4a.

Step 3.2 — Blocking issue: auto-recovery ladder

Triggered when blocking: true or exit code non-zero.

Step 1: Kill subprocess:

kill -TERM <pid>; sleep 5; kill -KILL <pid> 2>/dev/null || true

Step 2: Assess complexity → choose start model:

• Simple (syntax/params/config) → haiku
• Medium (logic/deps/env) → sonnet
• Complex (concurrency/perf/arch) → opus

Step 3: Recovery loop, max 3 attempts:

1. Dispatch diagnostic subagent at current model (input: last 200 lines of raw.log + run-spec.md; output: root_cause + fix_patch)
2. Apply fix in worktree
3. Rerun trigger with 5-min cap for quick validation
4. If passes → break (recovery succeeded), proceed to Stage 4a
5. If fails → upgrade model: haiku→sonnet→sonnet→opus→opus (cap at opus)

Step 4: All 3 attempts fail → unrecoverable:

1. Write iter-N/blocker-report.md (each attempt: model, root_cause, fix_applied, result)
2. Overwrite status.md: iter N/M · Stage 3 · BLOCKED · auto-recovery ladder exhausted
3. Append to user-log.md
4. scripts/escalate.sh "blocker_unrecoverable" "$RUN_ID"
5. If $COLLIE_AUTOITER_NOTIFY_CMD set: bash -c "$COLLIE_AUTOITER_NOTIFY_CMD" with env COLLIE_AUTOITER_EVENT=blocker_unrecoverable, COLLIE_AUTOITER_RUN_ID, COLLIE_AUTOITER_STATUS_FILE
6. Write state.json.status = "escalated"
7. RETURN — §3.5 terminal handles sentinel on next restart. Do NOT emit inline.

Observability:

• Overwrite status.md: iter N/M · Stage 3 · Observing · {n} issues found
• Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] iter-N Stage 3 → {n} issues recorded, {m} blocking

---

Stage 4a — Triage (opus, "reverse suspicion")

Dispatch single opus subagent.

System prompt requirements (G3):

• Must include the phrase "reverse suspicion"
• Must instruct: "Start by finding reasons why each issue is NOT real before concluding it is"
• Max 2 lines verbatim from observations.md (anchor prevention)

Inputs: iter-N/observations.md + run-spec.md + progress.md

Output: iter-N/triage.md

## ISSUE-{nnn}
verdict: Real | Discarded | Unclear
confidence: 1-5
rationale: <adversarial reasoning>

G8 Gate (Triage level)

condition	action
confidence ≥ 3, verdict Real/Unclear	Proceed to Stage 4b
confidence ≤ 2, verdict Real/Unclear	Write to progress.md DEFERRED pool, tag triage_low_confidence; skip Stage 4b
Discarded (any confidence)	Drop silently; do NOT write to DEFERRED

Observability:

• Overwrite status.md: iter N/M · Stage 4a · Triage · {n_real} Real, {n_deferred} DEFERRED
• Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] iter-N Stage 4a → triage complete ({n} → {m} to Deep Verify)

---

Stage 4b — Deep Verify (opus, per-issue parallel)

For each issue that passed G8 Triage gate, dispatch ONE opus subagent in parallel.

System prompt requirements (G3):

• Must include the phrase "adversarial"
• Must instruct: "Attempt proof of falsification before writing fix outline"
• Max 2 lines verbatim from observations.md

Output: iter-N/fixes/FIX-{nnn}.md

id: FIX-{nnn}
kind: correctness | optimization | mixed
severity: 1-5
fix_confidence: 1-5
root_cause: "<text — must be non-empty>"
reproduction_test: |
  <runnable test reproducing issue BEFORE fix>
fix_outline: "<what to change, where>"
why_root_cause: "<adversarial justification>"
dependencies: [FIX-xxx, ...]
uncertainty_tag: triage_unclear | none

G8 Gate (Deep Verify) + G2 Gate

condition	action
fix_confidence ≤ 2	DEFERRED pool, tag deep_verify_low_confidence; exclude from Stage 5.0
root_cause empty	DEFERRED pool, tag g2_incomplete; exclude from Stage 5.0
reproduction_test empty	DEFERRED pool, tag g2_incomplete; exclude from Stage 5.0
fix_confidence ≥ 3 AND both fields non-empty	Eligible for Stage 5.0

Observability:

• Overwrite status.md: iter N/M · Stage 4b · Deep Verify · {n} FIX in verification
• Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] iter-N Stage 4b → {n} issues in parallel Deep Verify

---

Stage 5.0 — Consolidated Fix Plan

⚠️ 本 stage 是 §Section 0 例外项 #2（受约束 inline）。仅汇总 4b deep-verify 输出到 fix-plan.md，禁止读源码。如需补充信息 → 按裁定基准 dispatch。

G7 check FIRST (before filling template)

const { jaccard, bucketize } = require('./skills/autoiter/lib/jaccard.js');
// currentTasksText: concatenated task subject strings from current iter FIX-*.md files
// prevTasksText: concatenated task subject strings from iter-(N-1)/fix-plan.md (empty string if iter=1)
const ratio = jaccard(currentTasksText, prevTasksText); // returns [0.0, 1.0]
const bucket = bucketize(ratio);                        // returns 1-5

See skills/autoiter/references/overfit-guards.md §G7 for bucket thresholds.

If bucket >= 4 AND consecutiveDelta0 >= 2:

1. Append to iter-N/summary.md: Jaccard ratio + bucket
2. Write state.json.status = "escalated"
3. scripts/escalate.sh "loop_no_progress" "$RUN_ID"
4. If $COLLIE_AUTOITER_NOTIFY_CMD set: notify with COLLIE_AUTOITER_EVENT=deadlock
5. RETURN — §3.5 terminal handles sentinel on next restart

Fill fix-plan.md

Only FIX entries with fix_confidence ≥ 3 AND non-empty root_cause AND non-empty reproduction_test are eligible.

Write iter-N/fix-plan.md using skills/autoiter/references/fix-plan-template.md:

1. 3 metadata lines (top):

   <!-- plan-source: <absolute path to iter-N/fix-plan.md> -->
   <!-- plan-topic: autoiter-iter-N-fixes -->
   <!-- plan-executor: collie:flow -->
   

2. Task Execution DAG (from FIX dependencies fields; independent FIX = same batch)
3. Task Details: root_cause → Why, fix_outline → How, reproduction_test → Verify
4. Impact Assessment: aggregate affected files; Reverse impact must be filled (write None — iter-local change if no shared-state impact)
5. E2E Assessment: inherit from run-spec.md — do NOT re-derive

Observability:

• Overwrite status.md: iter N/M · Stage 5.0 · Building fix-plan · {n} FIX eligible
• Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] iter-N Stage 5.0 → fix-plan.md built ({n} FIX)

---

Stage 5.1 — flow

Skill('collie:flow')

Input: iter-N/fix-plan.md. Runs full pipeline: TDD → implement → review → simplify → regression → [collie-final-review].

---

Stage 5.2 — G6 Diff Audit (INLINE, after Stage 5.1 returns)

⚠️ git diff --name-only 是 §Section 0 例外项 #3（inline 取文件清单不解析内容）。审计 diff 内容属"执行+分析"型，按裁定基准 dispatch。

Execute immediately after flow returns.

git diff HEAD~1..HEAD --name-only

For each changed file: verify it appears in fix-plan.md Task list "Key files", OR is a mechanical consequence of a listed fix (auto-generated file, build artifact).

If any diff line is NOT traceable to any FIX entry:

1. Log untraceable file + reason
2. Write state.json.status = "escalated"
3. scripts/escalate.sh "g6_diff_audit_failed" "$RUN_ID"
4. RETURN — §3.5 terminal handles sentinel on next restart

If audit passes → proceed to Stage 5.3.

See skills/autoiter/references/overfit-guards.md §G6 for full audit rules.

Observability:

• Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] iter-N Stage 5.2 → G6 diff audit PASS (or FAIL)

---

Stage 5.3 — Rerun + Record Scalar

⚠️ 启动 rerun bash 是 §Section 0 例外项 #1（inline）。raw.log 解析 / scalar 提取属"执行+分析"型，按裁定基准 dispatch。

cd $WORKTREE
bash -c "<trigger.invocation>" > $ITER_DIR/rerun.log 2>&1

Parse scalar from rerun.log using run-spec.trigger.scalar_extraction.

Write iter-N/summary.md:

# Summary — iter-N
scalar_before: <state.last_scalar>
scalar_after: <new_scalar>
scalar_delta: <new - before>
convergence: yes|no
decision: continue | stop_converged | stop_cap | stop_budget
fixes_applied: [FIX-001, FIX-002, ...]

Update state.json: { "last_scalar": <new_scalar>, "status": "iter_done" }

Observability:

• Overwrite status.md: iter N/M · Stage 5.3 · Rerun done · scalar={new} (was {old}, Δ={delta})
• Append user-log.md: narrative of this iter's outcome
• Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] iter-N Stage 5.3 → rerun done, scalar={new}

---

Stage 6 — Rollback & Stop Check

⚠️ "是否 rollback"决策 inline；执行 rollback 命令属"执行"型 + 涉及 ❌ 第 5 条（inline git reset），必须按裁定基准 dispatch。

Rollback decision

MUST consult skills/autoiter/references/stop-criterion.md for the authoritative rollback matrix before executing any revert. The inline table below is a quick-reference summary only; the reference document governs all edge cases.

Full matrix in skills/autoiter/references/stop-criterion.md. Summary:

primary_goal	scalar_delta	action
correctness	any	Never whole-iter rollback. Keep correctness FIX. Per-FIX revert optimization if scalar degrades.
optimization	degrades	Per-FIX revert all kind=optimization; force-keep kind=correctness
optimization	flat/improves	Keep all
both	degrades + ≥50% optimization FIX	Per-FIX revert optimization; keep correctness
both	degrades + ≥80% correctness FIX	Keep all (crash-fix priority)
both	degrades + 50-80% correctness	Per-FIX revert optimization; keep correctness
both	flat/improves	Keep all

Per-FIX revert:

git revert --no-commit <commit-sha>  # repeat for each optimization FIX being reverted
git commit -m "chore: revert optimization FIX(es) due to scalar regression (iter-N)"

Append rollback_log section to iter-N/summary.md for each reverted FIX.

Stop check (SC1-SC5, hybrid OR)

Full spec in skills/autoiter/references/stop-criterion.md.

ID	Condition	Terminal status
SC1	iter >= max_iterations	budget_exhausted
SC2	all_green reached OR scalar >= threshold	converged
SC3	Last 2 iters: |scalar_delta| ≤ ε (ε=0 for int 1-5; ε=0.01×|baseline| for continuous)	converged
SC4	tokens_used >= max_tokens OR elapsed >= max_wallclock_min	budget_exhausted
SC5	stop-steps-counter.js triggered (same error ×3 or no file changes ×5)	escalated

If any stop condition true:

1. Write final iter-N/summary.md decision field
2. Overwrite status.md: DONE · {reason} · scalar={final} (baseline={base}, Δ={total})
3. Append final entry to user-log.md
4. If $COLLIE_AUTOITER_NOTIFY_CMD set: bash -c "$COLLIE_AUTOITER_NOTIFY_CMD" with COLLIE_AUTOITER_EVENT=autoiter_done (or escalated/budget_exhausted)
5. Write state.json.status = <terminal status>
6. RETURN — do NOT emit sentinel inline. Preserve worktree. §3.5 terminal branch handles rm current-run + sentinel on next ralph-loop restart.
7. Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] Stage 6 → STOP ({reason})

If continue:

1. Increment iter: state.json.iter = N+1, status = "running"
2. Proceed to Stage 1
3. Stdout: [autoiter {runId}] Stage 6 → continue to iter-{N+1}

---

Observability (§14 — mandatory at every stage/iter boundary)

At every stage transition and iter boundary, update ALL of:

1. status.md (overwrite): iter N/M · Stage X · <description> · scalar=<val>
2. user-log.md (append): human-readable narrative
3. stdout tick: [autoiter {runId}] iter-N Stage X → ...
4. External notify (terminal events only): if $COLLIE_AUTOITER_NOTIFY_CMD set:

   COLLIE_AUTOITER_EVENT=<event> \
   COLLIE_AUTOITER_RUN_ID=<runId> \
   COLLIE_AUTOITER_STATUS_FILE=<path/to/status.md> \
   bash -c "$COLLIE_AUTOITER_NOTIFY_CMD"
   

   Terminal events: autoiter_done, escalated, budget_exhausted, blocker_unrecoverable, prepare_failed, deadlock

---

Key Invariants

1. Sentinel uniqueness: <promise>Collie: AUTOITER DONE</promise> emitted ONLY by §3.5 terminal branch. Never from Stage 3/5/6 inline.
2. run-spec.md is write-once: Written by cp in Branch B recovery; never modified after creation.
3. current-run cleared before sentinel: rm current-run THEN emit sentinel (crash-safe ordering).
4. Worktree preserved: On sentinel, worktree is NOT merged or removed. User reviews and decides.
5. G1 invariant: No test file modified unless FIX is kind=correctness with explicit reproduction_test new-file addition. See overfit-guards.md §G1.
6. autoiter-prepare idempotency: If prepare-report.md already exists, skip prepare entirely.
7. Nested calls rejected: COLLIE_AUTOITER_ACTIVE check prevents /autoiter inside /auto or another /autoiter.

Reference Files

• skills/autoiter/references/overfit-guards.md — G1-G8 rules (enforced at Stage 3 / Stage 5.0 / Stage 5.2)
• skills/autoiter/references/stop-criterion.md — SC1-SC5 + full rollback matrix
• skills/autoiter/references/fix-plan-template.md — Stage 5.0 template
• skills/autoiter/references/discovery-prompt.md — Stage 0.2 Discovery subagent system prompt
• skills/autoiter/references/iter-prompt.md — per-iter observation guidance
• skills/autoiter/lib/jaccard.js — G7 token-set Jaccard similarity (zero external deps)