Proofread presentation

Proofread Presentation

Validate an existing themed PRESENTASJON.md, safely fix mechanical issues, report content concerns, and update Proofread state only when blocking checks pass.

Output voice

Apply a lightweight human-voice pass to proofreading reports, warnings, and user-facing remediation. Be specific about the observed issue and the next action. Preserve quotations, accessibility text unless clarity requires a correction, project state, commands, and semantic markup contracts. Use the standalone unslop Skill for every proofreading report and, when requested to edit presentation copy, as a required full editorial pass using DISCOVERY.json.editorialPreferences.

Startup

Require DISCOVERY.json, PROJECT.json, PRESENTASJON.md, Node.js, and Marp CLI. Read the project-local themes/theme-lock.json, its selected Theme Manifest, declared CSS, and assets. Recompute the lock's SHA-256 fingerprints and validate the manifest contract described below before changing anything. A missing, modified, or incompatible Theme Package is fatal. Do not depend on another phase skill being installed.

Read the locked Theme Manifest and validate against its interface rather than hard-coding Editorial, Signal, or Field Notes behavior.

When the complete Presentation Skill Suite is installed, invoke the read-only presentation-validation dispatcher with the proofread profile before completion. If it is unavailable, report that full validation cannot run under the suite installation contract; do not install it automatically.

Safe mechanical fixes

• Add missing purpose-based alt text to meaningful media when intent is unambiguous from the Agenda and Media Specs.
• Use empty alt text for explicitly decorative images.
• Strip trailing whitespace from presenter notes.
• Correct a missing semantic Content Slot class when the slide's existing archetype and content make the intended slot unambiguous.

Never convert media to img-right, add class: invert, insert inline theme CSS, change an archetype, choose another variation, rewrite Media Intent, or delete content as an automatic fix.

Blocking validation

Theme and markup

• Front matter contains marp: true, the resolved theme ID, size: 16:9, paginate: true, and the presentation language.
• Front matter contains no copied theme CSS. Only the generated External Font Override style is permitted.
• Every slide declares exactly one supported Slide Archetype, one supported Archetype Variation, and the Theme Manifest's tonal state.
• Every populated node uses shared Semantic Slide Markup and Content Slots; no theme-specific semantic wrappers exist.
• Classification agrees with the Agenda and Media Spec visual type.

Accessibility and readability

• Meaningful Pictures, charts, and Diagrams have purpose-based alternative text; decorative media is absent from reading order.
• DOM order is heading, body or takeaway, media, then caption.
• Essential wording is real text rather than raster content.
• Computed contrast is at least 4.5:1 for body/supporting text, 3:1 for large headings, and 3:1 for meaningful non-text graphics.
• On the 1280×720 reference slide, titles are at least 54 px, headings 36 px, body and metric labels 28 px, captions and attribution 20 px, and pagination/context labels 18 px.
• Body line height is 1.25–1.5; display line height is at least 1.0. All-caps is limited to short labels and brief Signal headings.

Capacity, collision, and media

• Content does not exceed the selected composition's declared Content Capacity.
• No text or semantic media leaves the slide, overlaps another protected Content Slot, clips, scrolls, truncates, or sits within 32 px of an edge.
• Essential text never overlays raster media.
• Picture dimensions agree with Intended Media Orientation.
• Raster media is not enlarged beyond native size; fallback raster output is at least 2× displayed dimensions.
• Cropping preserves Media Intent; Diagram labels and chart values remain legible at 100% view.
• Theme grading preserves semantic colors and required contrast.

Any failure above blocks completion and is reported with slide numbers and the relevant archetype/slot.

Non-blocking content warnings

Report with slide numbers:

• Code fences or progressive-reveal syntax.
• More bullets than the archetype permits.
• Missing presenter notes or notes not in bullet format.
• A video sharing a slide with other content.
• A slide without a semantic heading.
• Mixed language, inconsistent glossary terminology, unexplained abbreviations, grammar concerns, or encoding problems.
• Expected media placeholders that have not yet been rendered.

Reference integrity

• Every Agenda Picture filename matches one IMAGE_SPEC.md entry and every Picture used by slides exists in that spec.
• Every Agenda Diagram filename matches one DIAGRAM_SPEC.md entry and every Diagram used by slides exists in that spec.
• No orphan Media Spec entry exists.
• Every source link used by slides has a successful source summary or appears in the reported fetch failures.
• Slide count remains within the confirmed estimate unless the user approved a different count.

Export parity

When HTML and PDF exist, confirm equal slide counts, 16:9 dimensions, text, media, and pagination. Compare PDF visually with the HTML Accessible Reference Output for layout shift, clipping, missing decoration, materially different color, and illegible media. A mismatch is blocking.

Completion

Report fixed issues, blocking failures, warnings, and reference results. Mark phases.proofread.status = "done" with a timestamp only when no blocking issue remains. Otherwise keep it pending. Require PROJECT.json to have projectType: "presentation" and preserve every unrelated phase record when updating Proofread.

The validation dispatcher must return zero before Proofread may be marked complete. A zero validator result is necessary but does not replace this Skill's mechanical-fix, user-review, and state-preservation requirements.