Critique

Skill Dragoon0x/dragoon-skills/skills/critique

design intelligence for ai coding agents. one unified cli, 36 commands across recon, review, build, plan, ship, test, reflect, power. zero npm deps.

Install

npx -y skills add Dragoon0x/dragoon-skills --skill critique

Assembled from the repository path, not quoted from the project. Check it against their README if it does not work.

One thing to look at

4 stars4 stars. Stars are a popularity signal and not a quality one, but at this level it is likely that nobody has read this closely except its author, and you would be relying on your own review.

What its author says it does

Copied from the file, not written here

Score a codebase's design quality 0-100 across six categories (typography, color, spacing, motion, accessibility, consistency) plus an overall weighted score. Every score is derived from concrete metrics in dragoon.json with transparent math, no LLM, no vibes. Use when the user asks "what's the design quality of this codebase", "rate my design", "audit the design system", or wants a CI gate for design. Includes a per-category breakdown explaining each deduction. Auto-scans if no manifest exists. Run as `node ~/.claude/skills/dragoon/skills/critique/scripts/critique.js [root]`.

SKILL.md

2.3 KB, as published. Nobody here has run it

/critique

0-100 scores for design quality. Transparent math. Every deduction is traceable to a metric in dragoon.json.

When to use

Run /critique when:

The user asks for a design quality score, audit, rating, or grade
Setting up a CI gate that fails when design quality drops below a threshold
Comparing design quality before and after a redesign
The user says "how good is this", "give me a score", "rate the design system"

What it produces

Six category scores plus an overall:

typography - font family count, scale ratio confidence, font size variant count
color - distinct color count, palette balance
spacing - grid detection confidence, spacing variant count
motion - easing variant count, duration variant count
accessibility - alt rate, button label rate, semantic tag presence
consistency - shadow variant count, radius variant count

Weighted overall:

typography 1.0  color 1.0  spacing 1.2  motion 0.8  accessibility 1.2  consistency 1.0

Each score includes a breakdown listing every deduction and reason. You can read exactly why your score is what it is.

Run it

node ~/.claude/skills/dragoon/skills/critique/scripts/critique.js [root]

Flags:

--manifest <p> use existing manifest instead of scanning
--json machine-readable
--threshold <n> exit non-zero if overall score below n (CI gate)
--no-breakdown show scores only
--quiet show only the final score
--help full usage

Use as a CI gate

In package.json:

"design:check": "node ~/.claude/skills/dragoon/skills/critique/scripts/critique.js --threshold 80 --quiet"

The command exits 1 if the overall score drops below 80, blocking the PR.