Idea refine

Idea Refine

Early-stage idea shaping: generate options, stress-test assumptions, then narrow to a testable direction. Distinct from planning-and-task-breakdown (execution) and spec-driven-development (requirements lock).

When to use

• Idea is directional but not actionable
• User wants alternatives before committing
• Trade-offs between 2–3 approaches need surfacing

When not to use

• Requirements are already agreed
• User wants immediate implementation
• Pure research with no decision deadline

Workflow

Phase 1 — Diverge (2–4 options)

• Restate the problem in one sentence
• Propose distinct approaches (not minor variants)
• For each: upside, downside, effort tier (S/M/L), key assumption

Phase 2 — Stress test

• What would make each option fail?
• What data or spike would de-risk the choice?
• What is explicitly out of scope?

Phase 3 — Converge

• Recommend one direction with rationale
• List what to validate in the next 1–2 hours/days
• Present design in short sections the user can approve or correct before locking scope
• Hand off to interview-me, spec-driven-development, or planning-and-task-breakdown

Before code

• Do not start implementation during brainstorming
• Do not auto-save specs or commit without explicit user request

Output template

## Idea refinement
- **Problem:**
- **Options considered:** (name + one-line summary each)
- **Recommendation:**
- **Why not the others:**
- **Next validation steps:**