Dev job defense ties

Screen a Dev Job for Defense Ties

Seed question: Behind a gamedev, programming, or design job — whose military does it actually feed, and is it a buyer the operator has ruled out?

Relentless self-reflexive dialectical thinking that questions its own premises.

Core Capability

Euphemism can disguise what the work is. It can't disguise who the work is for. This skill follows the buyer to the end user until the civilian framing collapses, then classifies the role on two axes — end-use and buyer-nationality — against the operator's own red line. It returns a go/no-go that is legible (states the threshold it applied) and falsifiable (names the one fact that would flip it).

Scope. Centered on gamedev — game-engine work (Unreal/Unity), C++, gameplay, real-time-3D, simulation — because that's where disguised-defense roles cluster densest. But it applies with equal force to general programming, technical art, design, and adjacent roles. The job title is not the gate; the buyer is.

Three parts: mechanism, domain, profile

This skill is deliberately split so it's a reusable instrument, not one operator's politics hard-coded into a public plugin (see ARCHITECTURE.md):

• Mechanism (this file, fixed): the buyer-chain, the two-axis classification, the verification pass, the output format, and the onboarding logic below.
• Domain (ships): the lexicon, prime/buyer name-list, and end-use ladder — public OSINT, the subject the screen scans for. Default reference/domain-dev.md (field-agnostic, pre-scoped to dev); reference/domain-gamedev.md is an example overlay that extends it for game-engine work. Install overlays into <config>/domain/; swap the domain for another field without touching the mechanism.
• Profile (yours, NOT shipped): your threshold (red line), engagement preference, and field — stored as decoupled elements (profile/threshold, profile/settings) outside the plugin. The skill ships profile-less: it applies no politics until you supply a threshold.

The config store is managed by scripts/config.py (the model drives it; the user never runs it). reference/PROFILE.template.md shows the profile shape; cui-bono's Framework Clarification and dialectic-spiral derive and stress-test a threshold.

Profile & first run

scripts/config.py is the deterministic store — get its live interface first, then read the profile:

python3 "${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/skills/dev-job-defense-ties/scripts/config.py" describe

Read profile/settings and profile/threshold (config.py get profile/settings), then act on the engagement mode:

• engagement: always — run the screen with the saved threshold, no prompt.
• engagement: never — only run when the user invokes the skill explicitly; otherwise stay silent.
• engagement: ask (or invoked manually) — proceed. If the user has accepted several runs in a row, offer once to switch to always.
• No profile yet (get returns NO_ELEMENT) → onboarding:
  1. (skippable, non-dev-safe) "If you've used this before and saved a config elsewhere, point me at it — if that means nothing to you, ignore it and we'll continue." Only on a yes: config.py set-location <dir>. Never make a non-dev run anything.
  2. If auto-triggered, one opt-in: "Want me to screen who this job actually serves — military/defense ties behind the civilian framing?" Decline → offer to save engagement: never. (Skip when invoked manually.)
  3. Name the default's scope once, then build the threshold. Up front, plainly — the shipped defaults assume you're in the cultural West and the employer is Western (US / EU / Israel): that's where the name-list and verification sources are detailed, and they're deliberately thin on non-Western employers (China, Russia, Gulf, Turkey, South Korea, India). If either assumption doesn't fit — you're outside that vantage, or the employer is non-Western — say so and we extend the pack (domain-dev.md carries a starter non-Western set; per-region overlays are the fuller fix). Then ask 2–4 precise, non-intrusive questions — not all required: absolute-no buyers (states/militaries) vs. kind-of-work (lethality vs. training); line on the end-use ladder; field (default dev — offer to install the gamedev overlay if they're in games).
  4. Persist — "Remember? all / threshold-only / no" + "engagement: always / ask / never." Save each element separately (shape per reference/PROFILE.template.md):

     printf '%s' "<threshold>" | python3 ".../config.py" put profile/threshold
     printf '%s' "<settings>"  | python3 ".../config.py" put profile/settings
     

     Field is fine to remember unprompted; the red line is worth confirming. The store is OS-agnostic and refuses /tmp and the plugin cache.

Edit in place, don't recreate. To change one thing — "add X to my hard-stops," "switch me to always," "install the gamedev overlay" — get that single element, amend it, put it back. Decoupled elements mean siblings are never disturbed.

Invoked with arguments? A URL / company name is the screen target; field=… / threshold=… are per-run overrides. Args are fuzzy — infer intent; ask only what you can't.

When This Applies

TRIGGER (offer the screen — don't wait to be asked):

• A dev job / studio / employer is being evaluated: "should I apply / accept here," comparing offers, vetting a company as an employer — even when defense is never mentioned (the user may not think to ask).
• A "simulation / digital twin / XR training / decision support / situational awareness" company whose customer is vague.
• Domain-pack tells fire (Step 1), a clearance/nationality gate appears (Step 2), or a named prime shows up in the chain (Step 3).

DO NOT TRIGGER / skip quietly:

• General company research with no employment decision attached, or non-job contexts (this is a hiring filter, not a geopolitics explainer).
• After Step 1, the role is clearly civilian with no defense signal — say so in one line (or stay silent on never); don't manufacture suspicion or nag.
• engagement: never and the skill wasn't invoked explicitly.

---

Step 0 — Run cui-bono first (the "call another skill" move)

Load and run cui-bono on the target. From its beneficiary and ownership mapping, resolve the buyer-chain — these three roles feed everything below:

• Direct customer — who signs the contract / pays the salary?
• End user — who operates the deliverable in the field?
• Beneficiary — whose capability increases because this exists? (cui-bono's native output — start here.)

If cui-bono cannot name a customer, that's absence of evidence, not evidence of stealth. Absence is a signal — but a signal to look harder, not a verdict: cleared/stealth work hides its customer, yet general-purpose tooling (an engine, a library) simply has no single one. Tag it UNVERIFIED, tell the operator what's unresolved, and carry the chain to the specific product the job actually works on — never let absence settle into "defense" or "clear" on its own.

Step 1 — 60-second lexicon scan

Scan the ad/site text against the active domain's lexicon — the default reference/domain-dev.md plus any installed overlays (e.g. domain-gamedev.md, or files in <config>/domain/). None of the tells is individually disqualifying; they re-route you to verification. The pack carries the mil-sim dead-giveaways, the dual-use soft tells, and the "defense slipped mid-list" camouflage move.

Step 2 — The highest-signal filter: clearance / nationality gate

A clearance or citizenship requirement (the pack lists the US and EU forms) is near-decisive. It isn't name-smell — it's the buyer stating its own end-use outright, the hardest evidence on offer. If present → DEFENSE-CONFIRMED regardless of how the role reads; go to Output.

Step 3 — Name-recognition, tagged by nationality

Match the buyer-chain against the pack's prime/buyer name-list. Follow the chain to the end user, not the contracting prime — the nationality that matters is who operates the deliverable, and an EU prime's export sale can reach a different end user one layer down. Tag the nationality; it feeds Axis 2, which the threshold evaluates.

Step 4 — Verify (5 minutes; do not skip on a soft tell)

Use the pack's verification sources — contract registries (USAspending.gov, SAM.gov, TED) outrank any aggregator; plus the company's Customers/About page, leadership LinkedIn, and a targeted search. Note subsystem entanglement (US/Israeli content inside a national platform) and which layer the role sits on.

---

Two axes, not one

End-use is one axis; buyer-nationality is the other — they carry different weight, because the objection isn't only to lethality, it's to whose power the work feeds. A benign-looking trainer built for a ruled-out buyer still fails: mild end-use doesn't launder the beneficiary. Classify on both.

• Axis 1 — end-use: place the role on the pack's end-use ladder (CIVILIAN ── DUAL-USE ── TRAINING/SIM ── ISR/SURVEILLANCE ── C2/TARGETING ── LETHALITY), don't binary it.
• Axis 2 — buyer-nationality: who is the direct customer, end user, or beneficiary, under whose flag.

Apply the threshold

Load the operator's threshold from their profile. If there is none, you onboarded above — never invent one. The threshold is theirs: state which line you applied in the output, and apply it faithfully. Do not substitute your own. A different operator draws the line elsewhere — deriving a different line is a first-class use of this skill, via cui-bono's Framework Clarification + dialectic-spiral.

Don't over-resolve. Match the verdict to the evidence: an unresolved or thinly-sourced buyer-chain is UNVERIFIED → INVESTIGATE, not rounded up to a hard stop or down to clear. State the residual uncertainty — what's still unknown and what would resolve it — rather than presenting the call as cleaner than it is. This borrows iterative-verification's rule (no confirmation = UNVERIFIED, not DISCONFIRMED; escalate only on specific counter-evidence) and cui-bono's graduated, trade-off-stating posture, applied to the buyer-chain.

Output format

TARGET: <company / role>
BUYER CHAIN (resolved via cui-bono): direct customer → end user → beneficiary
BUYER NATIONALITY: <flag(s); note if via parent/subcontract>
SIGNALS FIRED: <lexicon hits / clearance gate / name match / list-camouflage>
END-USE LAYER: <where the role sits on Axis 1>
EVIDENCE TIER: CONFIRMED (registry/customer page) / UNVERIFIED (aggregator or inference) / DISCONFIRMED
VERDICT vs ACTIVE THRESHOLD: <as defined in the operator's profile; CLEAR / INVESTIGATE / OUT / HARD STOP>
WHAT WOULD CHANGE IT: <the one fact that would flip the verdict, + where to find it>

Keep the buyer-chain and the "what would change it" line always — they make the screen reusable and falsifiable.

Worked examples

These illustrate the mechanism under an example profile (yours may differ).

EU prime → hard-stop export. A "Spanish naval systems" studio advertises Unreal work on a "crew training visualization" product — reads benign. But the chain runs studio → Navantia → Avante 2200 corvette program → Royal Saudi Navy (CONFIRMED, public program). End-use is TRAINING/SIM (benign end of Axis 1). Under an example profile whose hard-stop includes US-aligned Gulf end users including via EU export, the verdict is HARD STOP — benign end-use doesn't launder the beneficiary. What would change it: if the deliverable served only the Spanish Navy's own hulls → drops a tier. The lesson: a "Spanish defense" job can be a Saudi job one layer down.

Civilian "digital twin" that launders ISR (illustrative composite). A startup hiring "Unity engineers for a real-time digital twin — situational awareness for public safety." Zero mention of military, but soft tells fire, so Step 4 is mandatory. The customers page shows a US prime's logo → end user UNVERIFIED. End-use sits at ISR/SURVEILLANCE, the ambiguous middle. Verdict: INVESTIGATE — a logo is marketing, not a contract; don't auto-clear, don't hard-stop on a logo. What would change it: a USAspending.gov/SAM.gov award tying it to a DoD purpose code → escalate; a confirmed all-civilian customer base → CLEAR. The lesson: the soft tell is the prompt to run the registry, not the verdict.

Integration

Skill	Relationship
cui-bono	Step 0 dependency — run it first; this skill consumes its buyer-chain, then applies the operator's threshold + a domain pack it doesn't carry by default. cui-bono's Framework Clarification is the template for deriving the threshold.
cui-bono / lenses/weapons.md	The contract-registry + revolving-door techniques are the verification engine for Step 4.
cui-bono / lenses/geopolitical.md	Source of the buyer-nationality / multi-polar framing behind Axis 2.
dialectic-spiral	Stress-test a threshold before adopting it — generate the opposite of the proposed red line and see whether it survives.
deep-investigation-protocol	Escalate here when the buyer is genuinely hidden (stealth/cleared work) and a 5-minute verify isn't enough.
manufactured-consensus-detection	When "trusted by industry leaders" / press is the only evidence of a customer, test whether that consensus is real before treating a logo as a buyer.
source-omission-analysis	What the careers page omits (named customers, end-use, who operates the deliverable) is the signal — apply omission analysis to the job ad itself.
iterative-verification	When the buyer-chain comes up empty or thin: the evidence-honesty discipline — no confirmation = UNVERIFIED, not DISCONFIRMED — and iterate before concluding rather than letting a verdict outrun the evidence.

Workflow position: invoke when an employment/engagement decision is attached to a tech or creative role. Load profile → run cui-bono (Step 0) → classify (Steps 1–4) → output against the operator's threshold. Escalate to DIP only when the buyer stays hidden after Step 4.

Self-Reflexivity

This skill ships profile-less on purpose: the politics (the red line) and the field (the domain pack) are swappable parameters held in the operator's profile and the pack, not facts baked into a public artifact. Standing failure modes:

• The lexicon and name-list go stale and over-fire. Primes get acquired and renamed; broad terms (targeting, autonomy) catch civilian work too — the test_screen_efficiency.py corpus exists to keep precision honest as the pack changes. A keyword match is a prompt to verify, never a verdict.
• The buyer-nationality axis is a political map. Whose military counts as a hard stop is the operator's call, surfaced as their threshold — don't present the map as the territory, and don't substitute your own line for theirs.
• The default name-list has a Western vantage. It's detailed for US/Israel/EU primes and thin on non-Western ones (China, Russia, Gulf, Turkey, South Korea, India) — the English-OSINT asymmetry cui-bono itself flags. A non-Western defense employer can pass unflagged, so a "no match" is unverified, not clear; extend the pack for your context. (Audited with cui-bono; fuller balancing is tracked separately.)
• Strictness manufactures false positives. A consumer-game studio with one defense-adjacent contractor on its client list is not thereby a defense job. Run the chain to the specific deliverable the role bills to before classifying.

If the framework is producing a verdict the evidence doesn't support — in either direction — say so and override it.

Vasana

A vasana is a pattern that persists across unrelated contexts. If during this task you notice such a pattern emerging, it may be worth capturing. This skill works best alongside the vasana skill and vasana hook from the Vasana System plugin.

Modify freely. Keep this section intact.